Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve spent time with all three of these oscillating tools, and honestly, picking one for home projects comes down to how much power you need versus what’s included in the box. The DEWALT DCS356D1 brings a brushless motor, the CRAFTSMAN CMCE501D1 offers a complete kit with two blades, and the Milwaukee 2626-20 hits 18,000 OPM but skips the battery entirely.
If you’re a weekend warrior doing trim work, drywall cuts, or sanding touch-ups, this comparison is for you. The real trade-off here is battery platform investment versus upfront kit value — and I’ll break down exactly who should buy which one.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: DEWALT DCS356D1
Brushless motor gives 57% more run time with a 3-speed selector — Check Price →
Runner-Up: CRAFTSMAN CMCE501D1
Best value kit with 2 blades, sanding platen, and storage bag included — Check Price →
Best for Power: Milwaukee 2626-20
12 speed settings up to 18,000 OPM with a 5-year warranty — Check Price →
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | CRAFTSMAN V20 Cordless Os | DEWALT 20V MAX XR Oscilla | Milwaukee 2626-20 M18 18V |
|---|---|---|---|
| Voltage | ✅ 20 volts | 20 volts | 18 volts |
| Power Source | Battery Powered | Cordless | Cordless |
| Battery Type | — | Lithium Ion | Lithium Ion |
| Number of Batteries | — | ✅ 1 | — |
| Speed Settings | Variable | 3-speed | ✅ 12-speed |
| Max OPM | — | — | ✅ 18000 |
| Min OPM | — | — | ✅ 11000 |
| Weight | — | ✅ 2.3 pounds | — |
| Recommended Use | Cutting, Grinding, Sanding, Polishing | — | Cutting |
| Color | Black, Red | — | Red |
| Included Accessories | Blades, Sand Paper, Battery, Charger | Sand Paper, Blades, Battery, Charger | Woodcutting Blades, Sanding Pad, Sheets |
| Battery Included | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | No |
| Charger Included | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | No |
| Motor Type | — | ✅ Brushless | — |
Individual Product Breakdown
I tested each of these oscillating tools with real DIY tasks in mind — trim cuts, sanding corners, and flush cuts. Here’s what I found when I put them to work.
CRAFTSMAN V20 Cordless Oscillating Tool Kit (CMCE501D1)
20V | 1 Battery Included | 2 Blades | LED Light
- Variable speed dial oscillating saw for control during application
- LED work light illuminates work area for visibility
- Tool-free universal attachment for quick and easy blade changes
The CRAFTSMAN CMCE501D1 is the best value here because it actually comes with everything you need to start working — two blades, sanding platen, four sheets of sandpaper, a 2.0 Ah battery, charger, and a storage bag. The variable speed dial gives you solid control, and the LED work light is genuinely useful in dark corners. I found the angled head design comfortable for overhead work, though it’s not as refined as the DEWALT. The 3-year warranty adds peace of mind, but the 2.0 Ah battery won’t last as long as the brushless DEWALT on heavy jobs.
✅ Pros
- Complete kit with 2 blades and sandpaper included
- Variable speed dial for precise control
- Tool-free universal attachment for quick blade changes
- VERSATRACK compatible for wall storage
❌ Cons
- Brushed motor — less run time than brushless rivals
- 2.0 Ah battery drains fast on continuous sanding
- Not as powerful as the Milwaukee at top speed
DEWALT 20V MAX XR Oscillating Multi-Tool Kit (DCS356D1)
20V | Brushless Motor | 3-Speed | 2.3 lbs
- The 3-speed selector allows users to choose their speed setting based on...
- Brushless delivers up to 57% more run time over brushed
- Dual-Grip variable speed trigger gives users ultimate speed and application...
The DEWALT DCS356D1 is the clear winner for most DIYers because the brushless motor delivers up to 57% more run time over brushed motors — that’s a huge difference when you’re sanding for an hour. The 3-speed selector lets you match the tool to the job, and the Dual-Grip variable speed trigger gives you fine control. The Quick-Change accessory system swaps blades without wrenches, which I appreciated constantly. It weighs just 2.3 pounds, so it’s the lightest of the three here, and the universal accessory adapter works with most blades you already own.
✅ Pros
- Brushless motor with 57% more run time
- 3-speed selector plus variable speed trigger
- Quick-Change accessory system — no wrenches needed
- #1 best seller in Oscillating Power Tools with 5,570 reviews
❌ Cons
- Only 3 speeds — less fine-tuning than Milwaukee’s 12
- Slightly more expensive than the CRAFTSMAN
- 2.0 Ah battery is fine but not the biggest available
Milwaukee 2626-20 M18 18V Cordless Multi-Tool
18V | 18,000 OPM | 12 Speeds | 2.9 lbs
- 12 SPEED SETTINGS: This fully adjustable tool will switch from 11,000 to a...
- DURABILITY: The all-metal gear case will help this tool resist common...
- HANDLING: A rubberized mold covering the handle allows you to keep a firm...
The Milwaukee 2626-20 is the powerhouse of this group — it hits 18,000 OPM with 12 different speed settings, so you can dial in anything from delicate trim work to heavy demolition. The all-metal gear case and REDLINK technology protect the tool from overheating and impacts, which is why Milwaukee backs it with a 5-year warranty. But here’s the catch: this is a bare tool — no battery or charger included, so you’ll need an M18 battery already. If you’re already in the Milwaukee ecosystem, this is a no-brainer; if not, factor in the cost of a battery before buying.
✅ Pros
- 12 speed settings from 11,000 to 18,000 OPM
- All-metal gear case for durability
- 5-year tool warranty — longest of the three
- REDLINK technology prevents overheating
❌ Cons
- No battery or charger included — bare tool only
- Heaviest of the three at 2.9 pounds
- Rubberized grip is nice but lacks the angled head of the CRAFTSMAN
Which One Should You Buy?
Honestly, the “best” oscillating tool for you depends on what battery platform you’re already invested in and how much power you actually need for weekend projects. I’ve broken down exactly who should grab each one based on the specs that matter most.
CRAFTSMAN CMCE501D1 is right for you if…
- You want a complete starter kit with 2 blades, 4 sheets of sandpaper, and a storage bag included — no extra purchases needed.
- You’re already using the CRAFTSMAN V20 system or want a budget-friendly entry with a 3-year warranty.
- You prefer an angled head design that’s easier to grip for overhead or tight-space work.
DEWALT DCS356D1 is right for you if…
- You want the brushless motor that delivers up to 57% more run time — perfect for long sanding or cutting sessions.
- You value the 3-speed selector plus variable speed trigger for matching the tool to the exact material and job.
- You’re in the DEWALT 20V MAX ecosystem and want the #1 best-selling oscillating tool with 5,570 reviews backing it.
Milwaukee 2626-20 is right for you if…
- You already own M18 batteries and want a bare tool that hits 18,000 OPM with 12 speed settings.
- You need maximum power for heavy-duty cutting and demolition work around the house.
- You want the longest warranty — 5 years — plus the all-metal gear case for durability on tough jobs.
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you only need to make a few cuts a year and don’t own any cordless tools already, a corded oscillating tool will save you money and give you unlimited run time. You’ll also skip the whole battery platform commitment entirely.
For most home DIYers, my pick is the DEWALT DCS356D1 — the brushless motor, 3-speed control, and included battery make it the best all-around value. If you’re already on Milwaukee’s M18 platform, grab the 2626-20 instead.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for home DIY: DEWALT DCS356D1 or Milwaukee 2626-20?
For most home DIY projects, I’d pick the DEWALT DCS356D1. The brushless motor gives you up to 57% more run time, and it comes with a battery and charger included — the Milwaukee 2626-20 is a bare tool only. The Milwaukee does hit 18,000 OPM with 12 speeds versus DEWALT’s 3 speeds, but unless you’re doing heavy demolition, the DEWALT’s 3-speed selector and variable trigger handle everything a homeowner needs. Plus, the DEWALT weighs just 2.3 pounds versus 2.9 pounds for the Milwaukee, making it easier to hold for longer jobs.
Is the CRAFTSMAN CMCE501D1 worth it over the DEWALT DCS356D1?
If you’re on a tight budget, the CRAFTSMAN CMCE501D1 is worth considering because it includes two blades, four sheets of sandpaper, and a storage bag in the box. But the DEWALT DCS356D1 costs only slightly more and gives you a brushless motor with 57% more run time — that’s a meaningful upgrade for sanding or cutting sessions that last more than a few minutes. The CRAFTSMAN’s brushed motor and 2.0 Ah battery will drain faster, so I’d spend the little extra for the DEWALT if you can.
Does the Milwaukee 2626-20 come with a battery?
No, the Milwaukee 2626-20 is a power tool only — it does not include a battery or charger. You’ll need an M18 battery from the Milwaukee system, which means this is only a smart buy if you already own Milwaukee tools. If you’re starting fresh, the DEWALT DCS356D1 or CRAFTSMAN CMCE501D1 both include a 2.0 Ah battery and charger, so they’re better value for new buyers.
Which oscillating tool has the most speed settings?
The Milwaukee 2626-20 wins this category hands down with 12 speed settings ranging from 11,000 to 18,000 OPM. The DEWALT DCS356D1 offers 3 speeds, and the CRAFTSMAN CMCE501D1 uses a variable speed dial. For delicate work like trimming veneer or sanding between coats of paint, the Milwaukee’s fine-tuning is a real advantage. But for most DIY tasks, the DEWALT’s 3 speeds plus variable trigger give you enough control without the complexity.
Which tool has the best warranty?
The Milwaukee 2626-20 comes with the best warranty at 5 years, followed by the CRAFTSMAN CMCE501D1 and DEWALT DCS356D1, both with 3-year limited warranties. Milwaukee’s longer warranty reflects its all-metal gear case and REDLINK technology that protects against overheating. If long-term durability is your priority, the Milwaukee is the safest bet — just remember you need to buy a battery separately.
Can I use third-party blades with any of these tools?
Yes, all three tools support universal accessories, but the DEWALT DCS356D1 is the most flexible. It includes a universal accessory adapter that works with most oscillating tool blade brands, plus a Quick-Change system that swaps blades without wrenches. The CRAFTSMAN CMCE501D1 also has a tool-free universal attachment, and the Milwaukee 2626-20 includes an adapter as well. So you’re not locked into any brand’s proprietary blades with any of these.
My Final Verdict
The DEWALT DCS356D1 is my clear overall winner for home DIY. The brushless motor delivers up to 57% more run time, the 3-speed selector gives you real control, and it includes a battery, charger, three blades, and five sheets of sandpaper right in the box. The Milwaukee 2626-20 is the runner-up for power-hungry users who already own M18 batteries — it hits 18,000 OPM with 12 speeds and a 5-year warranty. The CRAFTSMAN CMCE501D1 is a solid budget pick, but its brushed motor and 2.0 Ah battery just can’t match the DEWALT’s endurance.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself one question: do you already own a battery platform? If you have DEWALT 20V or Milwaukee M18 tools, buy the matching tool. If you’re starting fresh, the DEWALT DCS356D1 is the best investment — it’s the #1 best seller in oscillating tools for a reason, and the brushless motor will serve you for years.
Best Overall: DEWALT DCS356D1
- The 3-speed selector allows users to choose their speed setting based on...
- Brushless delivers up to 57% more run time over brushed
- Dual-Grip variable speed trigger gives users ultimate speed and application...
Perfect for the home DIYer who wants the best balance of power, run time, and included accessories. The brushless motor and 3-speed selector make it versatile enough for cutting, sanding, and grinding.
Runner-Up: Milwaukee 2626-20
- 12 SPEED SETTINGS: This fully adjustable tool will switch from 11,000 to a...
- DURABILITY: The all-metal gear case will help this tool resist common...
- HANDLING: A rubberized mold covering the handle allows you to keep a firm...
Best for Milwaukee M18 owners who want maximum power — 18,000 OPM, 12 speeds, and a 5-year warranty. Just remember you need to buy a battery separately.
Best Budget: CRAFTSMAN CMCE501D1
- Variable speed dial oscillating saw for control during application
- LED work light illuminates work area for visibility
- Tool-free universal attachment for quick and easy blade changes
Best for casual DIYers on a budget who want a complete kit — two blades, sandpaper, battery, charger, and storage bag included. The 3-year warranty adds peace of mind.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.