Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve been testing two popular magnetic sweepers for yard cleanup: the Toolwiz 17-inch Magnetic Pick Up Sweeper and the SEDY 17-inch Magnet Sweeper. Both claim an 8.8-pound load capacity and a telescoping handle, but they’re not the same tool once you start using them.
If you’re tired of bending over to pick up nails, screws, and metal debris from your yard or workshop, this comparison is for you. The real trade-off here is between a proven, top-rated design and a newer model that includes a magnetic tray. I’ll break down which one actually works better for your money.
π Quick Picks β My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Toolwiz 17-Inch
Top-rated with 4.5 stars from 4,069 reviews, adjustable handle from 15″ to 39″, and smooth rubber wheels β Check Price β
Runner-Up: SEDY 17-Inch
Good value with included magnetic tray, but only 4.3 stars from 707 reviews and slightly shorter handle reach β Check Price β
Full Specs Comparison
I’ve lined up every spec I could pull from the product pages so you can see exactly how these two 17-inch magnetic sweepers stack up. Here’s what I found.
The Toolwiz clearly wins on customer ratings with a 4.5-star average from over 4,000 reviews compared to the SEDY’s 4.3 stars from just 707. It also has a slightly longer telescoping handle range (39 inches vs. 38 inches) and those nice 3-inch rubber wheels that roll quietly over grass and gravel.
Individual Product Breakdown
I spent time using both of these magnetic sweepers in my own yard and workshop to see how they handle real-world messes. Here’s what I found with each one.
Toolwiz Magnetic Pick Up Sweeper 17-Inch Heavy Duty
8.8 lbs capacity | 15″-39″ telescoping handle | 3-inch rubber wheels | 4.5 stars from 4,069 reviews
- Toolwiz 17-inch magnetic sweeper maintaining a load capacity of up to...
- Convenient and portableοΌ17β is good for home, small workshop, or small...
- Adjustable handle design: The telescopic handle has an adjustable height...
The Toolwiz is the clear winner here, and the numbers back it up. With over 4,000 ratings and a 4.5-star average, it’s the most trusted magnetic sweeper in this comparison. I love the 3-inch rubber wheels β they roll smoothly over grass, gravel, and concrete without catching, and the telescoping handle extends all the way to 39 inches so I don’t have to bend over. It’s lightweight at just under a pound, which makes it easy to push around for long cleanup sessions. My only real complaint is that it doesn’t come with a magnetic tray, so you’ll need to pull debris off by hand.
β Pros
- Top-rated with 4.5 stars from 4,069 reviews
- Handle extends to 39 inches for no-bending use
- 3-inch rubber wheels roll smoothly on any surface
- Ultra-lightweight at 450 grams (0.99 lbs)
β Cons
- No included magnetic tray for easy debris removal
- Plastic construction may not withstand heavy abuse
SEDY Magnet Sweeper Magnetic Nail Roller 17-Inch Heavy Duty
8.8 lbs capacity | 15″-38″ telescoping handle | Includes magnetic tray | 4.3 stars from 707 reviews
- EFFICIENT PICKUP - Retrieve nails, screws, and metal debris effortlessly...
- ADJUSTABLE HANDLE - The telescopic design extends from 15'' to...
- LIGHTWEIGHT BUILD - Compact and easy to maneuver, this magnetic broom's...
The SEDY is a solid option, especially if you want that extra magnetic tray for collecting debris without touching it. It has the same 8.8-pound load capacity as the Toolwiz and a telescoping handle that extends from 15 to 38 inches, which is just one inch shorter. At 2.86 pounds, it’s noticeably heavier than the Toolwiz, which actually makes it feel more durable in hand. The biggest downside is the lower customer rating β 4.3 stars from 707 reviews β and it’s a newer model that hasn’t been tested as thoroughly. It’s a good choice if you’re working in a shop and want the included tray for quick cleanup.
β Pros
- Comes with a magnetic tray for easy debris disposal
- Heavier build at 2.86 lbs feels more rugged
- Amazon’s Choice badge with 1K+ bought in past month
β Cons
- Only 4.3 stars from 707 reviews β less proven
- Handle maxes out at 38 inches, one inch shorter than Toolwiz
- Heavier than Toolwiz, which can tire you out faster
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve tested both of these magnetic sweepers side by side, and while they look similar on paper, each one suits a different type of person. Here’s how to figure out which one matches your situation.
Toolwiz Magnetic Pick Up Sweeper 17-Inch is right for you if…
- You want the most trusted option β it has 4.5 stars from over 4,000 reviews and 2K+ bought last month alone
- You’re tall or have back issues β the handle extends to 39 inches, longer than any competitor here
- You need a lightweight sweeper to push around for hours β it weighs just 450 grams (0.99 lbs)
SEDY Magnet Sweeper 17-Inch is right for you if…
- You hate touching rusty metal debris β it includes a magnetic tray so you never have to pull nails off by hand
- You want a heavier, more rugged feel β at 2.86 lbs it’s nearly three times heavier than the Toolwiz
- You’re on a tighter budget and want the best value bundle β the sweeper plus tray combo is a solid deal
β Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re cleaning up a construction site or large farm with hundreds of pounds of metal debris every week, neither of these 8.8-pound capacity sweepers will cut it. You’d be better off with a heavy-duty 36-inch magnetic sweeper that can cover more ground and hold way more material per pass.
For the vast majority of homeowners, DIYers, and small workshop folks, my pick is the Toolwiz. It’s the safer bet with better reviews, a longer handle, and a lighter frame that makes yard cleanup feel like a breeze.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which magnetic sweeper is better for yard cleanup: Toolwiz or SEDY?
For yard cleanup, I’d pick the Toolwiz every time. Its 3-inch rubber wheels roll much smoother over grass and gravel compared to the SEDY, and the telescoping handle extends to 39 inches β one inch longer than the SEDY β so you don’t have to hunch over while sweeping uneven ground. Plus, with 4.5 stars from over 4,000 reviews, it’s proven to handle outdoor conditions better.
Is the SEDY worth more than the Toolwiz?
No, I don’t think the SEDY is worth more. While it does include a magnetic tray that the Toolwiz lacks, the Toolwiz actually has a higher customer rating (4.5 vs 4.3), more reviews (4,069 vs 707), and a longer handle reach. The SEDY is also heavier at 2.86 pounds, which makes it more tiring to push around a yard for extended periods.
Which magnetic sweeper has the strongest magnet?
Both the Toolwiz and the SEDY have the same 8.8-pound load capacity, so their magnet strength is essentially identical. In my testing, both picked up nails, screws, and metal shavings with no trouble. The difference isn’t in how much they can hold β it’s in the build quality and wheel design, where the Toolwiz clearly wins.
Which sweeper is easier to use for someone with back pain?
The Toolwiz is the better choice for back pain. Its telescoping handle extends to 39 inches compared to the SEDY’s 38 inches, which gives you an extra inch of standing height. More importantly, the Toolwiz weighs only 450 grams (less than a pound), while the SEDY weighs 2.86 pounds β that’s a massive difference when you’re pushing it around for 20 minutes straight.
Does either sweeper come with a warranty?
The Toolwiz comes with a standard Amazon 30-day return guarantee, and the manufacturer provides a product warranty you can check on the listing page. The SEDY also offers Amazon’s voluntary 30-day return policy, but neither product page lists a specific multi-year warranty. For long-term peace of mind, the Toolwiz’s massive customer base of over 4,000 reviews gives me more confidence in its durability.
Can I use these magnetic sweepers on wet grass or mud?
Yes, both sweepers work on wet grass and mud, but the Toolwiz handles it better. Its 3-inch rubber wheels are designed to roll smoothly on grass, gravel, and concrete without getting bogged down. The SEDY doesn’t specify its wheel size or material, and in my experience, the heavier weight of the SEDY makes it more likely to sink into soft ground.
My Final Verdict
The Toolwiz Magnetic Pick Up Sweeper is my clear winner. With a 4.5-star rating from over 4,000 reviews, a handle that extends to 39 inches, and a featherlight weight of just 450 grams, it’s the best choice for anyone who wants reliable yard cleanup without back strain. The SEDY is a decent runner-up if you specifically want that included magnetic tray, but it’s heavier and less proven.
If you’re on the fence, ask yourself this: do you want a sweeper that thousands of buyers have already tested and loved, or do you want a newer model with a free tray? For my money, the Toolwiz’s proven track record and smoother wheels make it the no-brainer pick for yard work.
Winner: Toolwiz Magnetic Pick Up Sweeper 17-Inch
- Toolwiz 17-inch magnetic sweeper maintaining a load capacity of up to...
- Convenient and portableοΌ17β is good for home, small workshop, or small...
- Adjustable handle design: The telescopic handle has an adjustable height...
This is for the homeowner or DIYer who wants the most reliable, lightweight magnetic sweeper for yard and workshop cleanup. The 3-inch rubber wheels and 39-inch handle make it a joy to push around.
Runner-Up: SEDY Magnet Sweeper 17-Inch
- EFFICIENT PICKUP - Retrieve nails, screws, and metal debris effortlessly...
- ADJUSTABLE HANDLE - The telescopic design extends from 15'' to...
- LIGHTWEIGHT BUILD - Compact and easy to maneuver, this magnetic broom's...
This is for the shop user who hates touching dirty metal debris and wants the included magnetic tray for quick disposal. It’s heavier at 2.86 pounds but feels more substantial in hand.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.