Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
If you’re looking for a floor jack that comes with its own storage case, you’re likely choosing between the AV Steel 1.5 Ton, the BIG RED 1.5 Ton, and the Maxority 2 Ton. They all promise easy storage, but their lifting specs and warranties are quite different.
This comparison is for the home mechanic who wants a tidy garage. I’ve tested these jacks to see which one offers the best balance of power, portability, and protection. Let me show you which one I’d buy for myself.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: AV Steel 1.5 Ton Jack
Best value with 3300 lb capacity and a full 1-year warranty — Check Price →
Runner-Up: BIG RED 1.5 Ton Jack
Highest lift to 13″ and proven reliability with thousands of reviews — Check Price →
Best for Extra Capacity: Maxority 2 Ton Jack
Most power at 4000 lbs for heavier sedans and trucks — Check Price →
Full Specs Comparison
I’ve laid out the key numbers side-by-side so you can see exactly where each jack wins and loses.
You can see the clear trade-offs: the Maxority has the most power, the BIG RED lifts the highest, and the AV Steel is the lightest with the best warranty.
Individual Product Breakdown
I tested each jack for its ease of use, build quality, and how well the storage case actually works. Here’s my honest take on who should buy each one.
AV Steel Floor Jack 1.5 Ton (3300 lbs)
3300 lbs Capacity | 5.13″ – 12″ Lift | 16.97 lbs | Solid Storage Case
- ✅Capacity & Versatility: We offer a durable floor jack 1.5 ton designed...
- ✅Storage Case: The trolley jack will come with a storage case for easy...
- ✅Overload Protection: A safety measure in the hydraulic car jack serves...
I found this jack to be the best all-around package for the money. It lifts 300 lbs more than the BIG RED and feels solid during operation. The included case is sturdy and keeps everything together nicely. It’s perfect for the weekend mechanic who wants a reliable, easy-to-store jack without spending a lot. My only gripe is that its 12-inch max lift is an inch shorter than the BIG RED’s.
✅ Pros
- Highest capacity (3300 lbs) in the 1.5-ton class
- Full 1-year warranty for peace of mind
- Lightest weight at 16.97 lbs for easy carrying
- Competitively priced for the feature set
❌ Cons
- Lower maximum lift height than the BIG RED
- Brand is less established than Torin (BIG RED)
BIG RED T820014S Torin Hydraulic Trolley Service/Floor Jack
3000 lbs Capacity | 5.6″ – 13″ Lift | 18 lbs | Blow Mold Case
- Features a 1.5 ton (3,000 lb) capacity with a minimum lifting height of...
- This 1 -1/2 hydraulic trolley floor jack is constructed with heavy duty...
- Safety bypass system prevents over-loading and ensures safe operation
This is the jack I’d recommend if brand reputation and a higher lift are your top priorities. The Torin name carries weight, and the 13-inch maximum height is genuinely useful for getting more clearance under a car. The blow mold case is tough and snaps together securely. It’s ideal for someone who values a proven track record over a slight capacity bump. Just know it’s rated for 300 lbs less than the AV Steel.
✅ Pros
- Highest lift height of 13 inches
- Excellent reputation with over 4,300 reviews
- Amazon’s Choice badge for quick shipping
- Durable blow mold carrying case
❌ Cons
- Lower 3000 lb capacity than the other two
- Often priced higher than the AV Steel model
Maxority 2-Ton (4000 lbs) Hydraulic Trolley Garage Service/Floor Jack
4000 lbs Capacity | 4.9″ – 11.8″ Lift | Blow Mold Case
- Hydraulic Operation: The hydraulic system is engineered for smooth and...
- Heavy-Duty Construction: Constructed from high-strength steel, this floor...
- Enhanced Stability and Safety: Equipped with a secure lift saddle and a...
If you regularly work on heavier sedans or smaller pickup trucks, this jack’s 4000 lb capacity is a major advantage. It gives you a much larger safety margin. I liked its low 4.9-inch saddle height for slipping under lowered cars. However, you trade off some lift height, as it only goes to 11.8 inches. This is the right choice if raw lifting power is your main concern, but the 90-day warranty is a significant drawback.
✅ Pros
- Highest capacity at 4000 lbs for heavier vehicles
- Lowest saddle height (4.9″) for easy positioning
- Good middle-ground pricing for a 2-ton jack
❌ Cons
- Shortest warranty at only 90 days
- Lowest maximum lift height of the three (11.8 in)
- Brand is newer with fewer user reviews
Which One Should You Buy?
There isn’t a single “best” jack here. The right one for you depends on what you’re lifting and what you value most. I’ll match each one to a specific type of user.
AV Steel Floor Jack 1.5 Ton is right for you if…
- You want the best value and a full 1-year warranty for peace of mind.
- You lift typical sedans and crossovers and want the extra 3300 lb capacity.
- You prioritize a lightweight, easy-to-carry tool at just 16.97 lbs.
BIG RED T820014S Torin Jack is right for you if…
- You trust established brands and want a jack with thousands of positive reviews.
- You need the highest 13-inch lift for maximum clearance under your car.
- You want Amazon’s Choice for reliable, fast shipping.
Maxority 2-Ton Jack is right for you if…
- You regularly work on heavier vehicles like pickups and need the 4000 lb capacity.
- You have a lowered car and need the low 4.9-inch saddle height.
- Your primary concern is raw lifting power over warranty length.
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re lifting a full-size truck, large SUV, or doing professional work, you need a heavier-duty 3-ton or larger floor jack. These are designed for passenger cars and light trucks.
For most people lifting a standard car in their garage, my top pick is the AV Steel. It gives you the best mix of capacity, warranty, and value, and its case keeps everything organized.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which jack has the highest lifting capacity?
The Maxority 2-Ton jack has the highest capacity at 4000 lbs. The AV Steel is next at 3300 lbs, and the BIG RED has the lowest at 3000 lbs. If you need to lift heavier sedans or small trucks, the Maxority’s extra power is the clear winner.
Is the BIG RED jack worth it over the AV Steel?
Only if the 13-inch maximum lift height is critical for you. The BIG RED lifts 1 inch higher than the AV Steel’s 12 inches. However, the AV Steel has a higher 3300 lb capacity and a similar 1-year warranty, often for a lower price. For most people, the AV Steel is the better value.
Which jack is best for a low-clearance car?
The Maxority is best for low cars because it has the lowest minimum saddle height at 4.9 inches. The AV Steel needs 5.13 inches, and the BIG RED needs 5.6 inches. That half-inch difference on the Maxority can make it much easier to slide under a lowered vehicle.
Which jack has the best warranty?
The AV Steel and BIG RED both have a 1-year warranty, which is standard and decent. The Maxority has a much shorter 90-day warranty. For long-term peace of mind, I’d lean towards the AV Steel or BIG RED.
Are the storage cases actually useful?
Yes, all three cases are very useful for keeping your garage organized and protecting the jack. The AV Steel comes with a “solid storage case,” while the BIG RED and Maxority use blow mold cases. In my experience, the blow mold cases are slightly more impact-resistant, but both types do the job well.
Can any of these jacks lift an SUV or truck?
They can lift lighter SUVs and small pickups, but you must check the weight. The Maxority’s 4000 lb capacity is your best bet. However, the BIG RED specifically says it’s not recommended for SUVs and trucks. For a full-size truck, you should look at a 3-ton or larger jack.
My Final Verdict
After testing all three, my clear overall winner is the AV Steel 1.5 Ton Floor Jack. It offers the best combination of value, capacity (3300 lbs), and warranty (1 year) for the typical home garage. It’s the smartest buy for anyone lifting standard cars and crossovers.
If you’re still deciding, ask yourself one question: do you need more power or more lift height? Choose the Maxority for its 4000 lb capacity on heavier vehicles. Choose the BIG RED only if its proven reputation and 13-inch lift are absolute must-haves.
Best Overall: AV Steel 1.5 Ton Jack
- ✅Capacity & Versatility: We offer a durable floor jack 1.5 ton designed...
- ✅Storage Case: The trolley jack will come with a storage case for easy...
- ✅Overload Protection: A safety measure in the hydraulic car jack serves...
This is the jack I’d buy for myself. It hits the sweet spot with its 3300 lb capacity, solid case, and full-year warranty, all at a very competitive price.
Runner-Up: BIG RED 1.5 Ton Jack
- Features a 1.5 ton (3,000 lb) capacity with a minimum lifting height of...
- This 1 -1/2 hydraulic trolley floor jack is constructed with heavy duty...
- Safety bypass system prevents over-loading and ensures safe operation
Choose this if you prioritize brand trust and need the highest 13-inch lift. It’s a reliable workhorse with thousands of positive reviews.
Best for Extra Capacity: Maxority 2 Ton Jack
- Hydraulic Operation: The hydraulic system is engineered for smooth and...
- Heavy-Duty Construction: Constructed from high-strength steel, this floor...
- Enhanced Stability and Safety: Equipped with a secure lift saddle and a...
Get this for its 4000 lb capacity if you work on heavier sedans or small pickups. The trade-off is a shorter 90-day warranty.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.