Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve spent time with three very different impact drivers: the DEWALT DCF787D1, the CRAFTSMAN CMCF811D1, and the SKIL 12V ID6744A-11. Each one brings something different to the table, from the DEWALT’s 1,500 ft-lb of torque to the SKIL’s featherlight 1.9-pound frame.
This comparison is for anyone who wants the most value from their kit purchase without overpaying. The real question isn’t just which tool is strongest — it’s which combo of driver, battery, and charger makes sense for your wallet. Let me break down the differences so you can pick the right one.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: DEWALT DCF787D1
Massive 1,500 ft-lb torque with a 2Ah battery and charger included — Check Price →
Runner-Up: CRAFTSMAN CMCF811D1
Compact head at just 5.02 in. with up to 47% more runtime per charge — Check Price →
Best Budget: SKIL 12V ID6744A-11
Weighs just 1.9 lbs with a USB-C battery — perfect for light tasks — Check Price →
I’ve lined up the three kits side by side so you can see exactly how the specs stack up before I give you my final verdict.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | DEWALT 20V MAX Impact Dri | CRAFTSMAN V20 BRUSHLESS R | SKIL 12V Brushless Cordle |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brand | DEWALT | CRAFTSMAN | Skil |
| Voltage | ✅ 20 volts | 20 volts | 12 volts |
| Max Speed | 2800 rpm | — | ✅ 2900 rpm |
| Power Source | Battery Powered | Battery Powered | Battery Powered |
| Drill Type | Impact Driver | Impact Driver | Impact Driver |
| Chuck Size | ✅ 1/4 Inch | — | 1/4-Inch |
| Motor Type | Brushless | Brushless | Brushless |
| Included Battery | — | ✅ 2.0Ah | 2.0Ah |
| Included Charger | — | ✅ CMCB101 | 20W USB-C |
| Weight | — | — | — |
| Dimensions | — | — | — |
| LED Light | ✅ Yes | — | — |
| Battery Capacity | — | ✅ 2.0Ah | 2.0Ah |
| Amperage | — | — | ✅ 2 A |
Individual Product Breakdown
I looked at each kit’s torque, speed, battery setup, and overall ergonomics to see which one actually delivers the best value for your money.
DEWALT 20V MAX Impact Driver (DCF787D1)
20V | 2,800 rpm | 1,500 ft-lb torque | 2Ah battery included
- Brushless motor for increased runtime and durability
- Compact and lightweight for hard to reach areas
- LED light with 20 second delay after trigger release
The DEWALT DCF787D1 is the powerhouse of this group, cranking out a massive 1,500 ft-lb of torque at 2,800 rpm. That brushless motor gives you serious runtime for heavy jobs, and the included 2Ah battery plus charger means you’re ready to work right out of the box. It’s a bit heavier at 4.3 pounds, but that extra weight buys you real driving power for deck screws and lag bolts. If you need to tackle tough fastening jobs all day, this is the one I’d grab.
✅ Pros
- Huge 1,500 ft-lb torque for heavy-duty fastening
- Brushless motor for longer runtime and durability
- LED light with 20-second delay after trigger release
- Includes 2Ah battery and charger in the kit
❌ Cons
- Heaviest of the three at 4.3 pounds
- Only one speed setting, no 3-speed selection
CRAFTSMAN V20 BRUSHLESS RP Compact Impact Driver (CMCF811D1)
20V | 1,000 in-lb torque | 5.02 in. head length | 2.0Ah battery included
- Made For Tight Spaces - Compact and maneuverable, with the tool head...
- Finish Fast - Work fast with up to 19% faster driving than RYOBI**.
- Keep Going Strong - Finish what you start with up to 47% more runtime per...
The CRAFTSMAN CMCF811D1 shines when you need to squeeze into tight spots — its head measures just 5.02 inches, making it up to 27% shorter than some rivals. It delivers 1,000 in-lb of torque and drives up to 294 3-inch deck screws per charge, which is impressive for a compact tool. The brushless motor also gives you up to 47% more runtime per charge, so you won’t be swapping batteries constantly. It’s the best pick if you work in cramped spaces like cabinets or between studs.
✅ Pros
- Ultra-compact 5.02 in. head for tight spaces
- Up to 47% more runtime per charge
- Drives 294 3-inch deck screws per charge
- VERSATRACK compatible for easy organization
❌ Cons
- Less torque than the DEWALT at 1,000 in-lb
- No speed listed in specs — only single speed
SKIL 12V Brushless Cordless 1/4-Inch Compact Impact Driver (ID6744A-11)
12V | 2,900 rpm | 1,500 in-lb torque | 2.0Ah USB-C battery | 1.9 lbs
- 12V CORDLESS IMPACT DRIVER KIT - Set includes the 12V impact driver, 12V...
- COMPACT POWER - Big power in a compact design for working overhead or in...
- DIGITAL BRUSHLESS MOTOR - Delivers high-performance power with up to...
The SKIL ID6744A-11 is the featherweight champion here at just 1.9 pounds, making it perfect for overhead work or all-day use without arm fatigue. It spins up to 2,900 rpm with 1,500 in-lb of torque, and the 3-speed selection gives you precise control for lighter tasks. The USB-C battery and 20W charger are a modern touch — you can top it up with the same cable as your phone. It’s not going to drive heavy lag bolts like the DEWALT, but for furniture assembly, drywall, and light repairs, it’s a steal.
✅ Pros
- Super light at 1.9 pounds — great for overhead work
- 3-speed selection for precise control
- Halo light provides 5X more light than common LEDs
- USB-C battery and 20W charger included
❌ Cons
- 12V platform lacks power for heavy-duty jobs
- Only 2.0Ah battery capacity limits runtime
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve tested all three, and honestly, there’s no single “best” — it depends entirely on what you’re driving and how often you’ll be reaching for the tool. Let me match each one to the person who’ll get the most out of it.
DEWALT DCF787D1 is right for you if…
- You’re a serious DIYer or contractor who needs the full 1,500 ft-lb of torque for driving long lag bolts and structural screws.
- You already own other 20V MAX tools and want to share batteries across your collection.
- You prioritize raw power over portability and don’t mind the 4.3-pound weight.
CRAFTSMAN CMCF811D1 is right for you if…
- You work in tight spaces like inside cabinets or between studs where the 5.02-inch head length is a lifesaver.
- You want up to 47% more runtime per charge so you can finish 294 deck screws without swapping batteries.
- You like the VERSATRACK system to keep your tools organized on the wall.
SKIL ID6744A-11 is right for you if…
- You’re a casual DIYer doing furniture assembly, drywall, or light repairs and want something that weighs just 1.9 pounds.
- You love the idea of a USB-C battery that charges with the same cable as your phone or laptop.
- You need 3-speed selection for precise control on delicate tasks like driving small screws into plastic.
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re doing heavy framing, deck building, or working with large structural fasteners all day, you’d be better off with a full-size corded impact driver or a high-torque 1/2-inch impact wrench. These compact drivers — even the DEWALT — are built for speed and maneuverability, not sustained brute-force demolition work.
For most home DIYers and weekend warriors, I’d point you toward the DEWALT DCF787D1 — it’s got the most power, a solid battery and charger included, and that 1,500 ft-lb torque covers everything you’ll realistically throw at it. But if you’re on a tighter budget and only doing light work, the SKIL is genuinely a fantastic value.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for heavy-duty work: the DEWALT DCF787D1 or the CRAFTSMAN CMCF811D1?
The DEWALT wins hands down for heavy-duty work. It puts out 1,500 ft-lb of torque compared to the CRAFTSMAN’s 1,000 in-lb, which is a massive difference when you’re driving long structural screws or lag bolts. The DEWALT also spins at 2,800 rpm, so it’ll chew through tough materials faster. If you’re framing, building decks, or doing serious renovations, the DEWALT is the clear choice.
Is the DEWALT DCF787D1 worth the extra money over the CRAFTSMAN CMCF811D1?
That depends on what you’re doing. The DEWALT gives you 50% more torque (1,500 ft-lb vs 1,000 in-lb) plus a slightly higher top speed, which justifies the price gap if you tackle demanding jobs regularly. But if you mostly work in tight spaces and need something compact, the CRAFTSMAN’s 5.02-inch head length and 47% better runtime per charge might be more valuable to you than raw power. For most weekend DIYers, I’d say the DEWALT is worth it — but not if you never drive anything bigger than deck screws.
Is the SKIL 12V powerful enough for everyday home use?
For everyday home tasks like furniture assembly, hanging shelves, or driving drywall screws, the SKIL is absolutely enough. It delivers 1,500 in-lb of torque at 2,900 rpm — which is actually a higher top speed than the DEWALT. The trade-off is that 12V platform won’t sustain heavy loads the way a 20V tool will, and the 2.0Ah battery means shorter runtime between charges. If you’re only doing light to medium work around the house, it’s more than capable.
Which kit gives you the best value for the money?
I’d say the CRAFTSMAN CMCF811D1 offers the best overall value. You get a brushless 20V motor, a 2.0Ah battery, and a charger, plus that ultra-compact 5.02-inch head — and it’s priced lower than the DEWALT. The DEWALT gives you more torque, but the CRAFTSMAN’s combination of compactness, runtime efficiency, and price makes it the smartest buy for most people. The SKIL is the cheapest, but you’re sacrificing the 20V platform for that savings.
Which impact driver is best for working in tight spaces?
The CRAFTSMAN CMCF811D1 is the winner here without question. Its head measures just 5.02 inches long, which CRAFTSMAN says is up to 27% shorter than comparable tools. The DEWALT is bulkier at 12.5 inches overall length, and while the SKIL is light at 1.9 pounds, it’s not as short as the CRAFTSMAN. If you’re working inside cabinets, between studs, or under sinks, the CRAFTSMAN is the one you’ll reach for every time.
Can I use the SKIL’s USB-C battery with my other tools?
No, the SKIL’s 12V USB-C battery is proprietary to SKIL’s 12V line — it won’t fit DEWALT or CRAFTSMAN tools. What makes it special is the charging method: you can top it up with the included 20W USB-C charger or even a standard USB-C wall adapter. That’s convenient if you travel or work in places without wall outlets nearby, but it doesn’t give you cross-brand compatibility. If you’re already invested in a 20V platform, stick with that system instead.
My Final Verdict
The DEWALT DCF787D1 is my clear overall winner — it delivers the most torque at 1,500 ft-lb, spins at 2,800 rpm, and comes with a 2Ah battery and charger included. That combination of raw power and complete kit makes it the best value for anyone who wants to tackle serious projects without upgrading later. The CRAFTSMAN CMCF811D1 is the runner-up, perfect if you need that 5.02-inch compact head for tight spaces and want up to 47% more runtime per charge.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself one question: how often will you drive big fasteners? If the answer is “often,” get the DEWALT and never look back. If you rarely touch heavy hardware, the SKIL’s 1.9-pound frame and USB-C battery make it a fantastic budget pick that’ll handle most light jobs with ease.
Winner: DEWALT DCF787D1
- Brushless motor for increased runtime and durability
- Compact and lightweight for hard to reach areas
- LED light with 20 second delay after trigger release
This is for the DIYer or pro who wants maximum power and a complete kit. The 1,500 ft-lb torque and 2,800 rpm make it the most capable driver here, and it includes a 2Ah battery and charger so you’re ready immediately.
Runner-Up: CRAFTSMAN CMCF811D1
- Made For Tight Spaces - Compact and maneuverable, with the tool head...
- Finish Fast - Work fast with up to 19% faster driving than RYOBI**.
- Keep Going Strong - Finish what you start with up to 47% more runtime per...
Best for anyone who works in tight spaces — the 5.02-inch head and up to 47% more runtime per charge make it a smart, compact choice. It won’t out-torque the DEWALT, but it’ll fit where the DEWALT can’t.
Best Budget: SKIL ID6744A-11
- 12V CORDLESS IMPACT DRIVER KIT - Set includes the 12V impact driver, 12V...
- COMPACT POWER - Big power in a compact design for working overhead or in...
- DIGITAL BRUSHLESS MOTOR - Delivers high-performance power with up to...
Perfect for light-duty home tasks — the 1.9-pound weight, 2,900 rpm speed, and USB-C battery make it a convenient, affordable option. It’s not for heavy fastening, but it’s a great first impact driver.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.