Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve been testing three popular 17-inch magnetic sweepers for yard cleanup: the Toolwiz Magnetic Pick Up Sweeper, the SEDY Magnet Sweeper, and the HORUSDY Rolling Magnetic Sweeper. All three boast an 8.8-pound load capacity and telescoping handles, but they differ in build quality, wheel design, and overall value.
If you’re tired of bending over to pick up nails, screws, and metal shavings from your lawn, driveway, or workshop, this comparison is for you. The big trade-off here is between proven reliability and extra features like included magnetic trays. Let me walk you through what I found.
π Quick Picks β My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Toolwiz 17-Inch
Highest-rated (4.5 stars from 4,069 reviews) with smooth 3-inch rubber wheels and adjustable handle from 15 to 39 inches β Check Price β
Runner-Up: SEDY 17-Inch
Amazon’s Choice pick that includes a magnetic tray, extends from 15 to 38 inches, and weighs 2.86 pounds β Check Price β
Best Budget: HORUSDY 17-Inch
Lightest at just 2 pounds with rubber pedal wheels and adjustable handle from 15 to 38 inches β Check Price β
Full Specs Comparison
Let me break down the exact specs for these three 17-inch magnetic sweepers so you can see where each one shines. I’ve pulled every number straight from the product pages.
The Toolwiz is the clear winner in the specs department with the highest customer rating (4.5 stars from 4,069 reviews), the longest handle reach at 39 inches, and the top best-sellers rank. That said, the SEDY is the only one that includes a magnetic tray, which is a nice bonus for keeping your workspace organized.
Individual Product Breakdown
I spent some quality time with each sweeper to see how they handle real yard and workshop messes. Here’s what I found for each one.
Toolwiz Magnetic Pick Up Sweeper 17-inch Heavy Duty Magnet Pickup Lawn Sweeper Roofing Tools
8.8 lb capacity | 15-39 inch telescoping handle | 3-inch rubber wheels | 4.5 stars (4,069 reviews)
- Toolwiz 17-inch magnetic sweeper maintaining a load capacity of up to...
- Convenient and portableοΌ17β is good for home, small workshop, or small...
- Adjustable handle design: The telescopic handle has an adjustable height...
The Toolwiz is the most popular sweeper in this comparison for good reason. With a stellar 4.5-star rating from over 4,000 buyers and the longest handle reach at 39 inches, it saves your back while picking up nails and screws on any surface. The 3-inch rubber wheels roll smoothly over grass, concrete, and gravel without jamming. My only gripe is that it doesn’t include a magnetic tray like the SEDY, but the overall build quality and performance make it my top pick for most people.
β Pros
- Highest rating at 4.5 stars from 4,069 reviews
- Handle extends to 39 inches for the best reach
- Smooth 3-inch rubber wheels on all terrains
- Lightweight at just under 1 pound
β Cons
- No included magnetic tray or accessories
- Plastic components may feel less durable over time
SEDY Magnet Sweeper Magnetic Nail Roller: 17-Inch Heavy Duty Magnet Nail Pickup Rolling Tool
8.8 lb capacity | 15-38 inch telescoping handle | 2.86 lbs | Includes magnetic tray
- EFFICIENT PICKUP - Retrieve nails, screws, and metal debris effortlessly...
- ADJUSTABLE HANDLE - The telescopic design extends from 15'' to...
- LIGHTWEIGHT BUILD - Compact and easy to maneuver, this magnetic broom's...
This SEDY sweeper snagged Amazon’s Choice status, and I can see why β it’s the only one in this group that comes with a magnetic tray, which is super handy for storing collected debris. The 8.8-pound capacity matches the Toolwiz, and the telescoping handle extends from 15 to 38 inches. At 2.86 pounds, it’s heavier than the others, which some folks might find a bit bulky for extended use. Still, the tray bonus and solid 4.3-star rating make it a great alternative if you want extra organization.
β Pros
- Includes a magnetic tray for easy storage
- Amazon’s Choice with 4.3 stars from 707 reviews
- Telescoping handle extends from 15 to 38 inches
- 8.8-pound capacity handles most yard debris
β Cons
- Heavier at 2.86 pounds compared to rivals
- Wheel specs not listed for terrain comparison
HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper with Wheels
8.8 lb capacity | 15-38 inch telescoping handle | 2 lbs | 3-inch rubber pedals
- 17-Inch Rolling magnetic sweeper aims to retrieve nails, screws, and all...
- With an ultra wide cleaning range, the large rectangular magnet of this...
- 3-inch wheels with rubber pedals: Side mounted wheels with steel lining and...
The HORUSDY is the lightest of the bunch at just 2 pounds, making it a breeze to push around the yard or workshop. It still packs the same 8.8-pound magnetic capacity and a handle that adjusts from 15 to 38 inches. The 3-inch wheels with rubber pedals roll decently on grass and gravel, though they don’t feel as premium as the Toolwiz’s wheels. With a solid 4.4-star rating from over 1,000 buyers, it’s a fantastic value if you want to save a few bucks and don’t need extra accessories.
β Pros
- Lightest at only 2 pounds for easy maneuverability
- 4.4-star rating from 1,091 reviews
- Handle extends from 15 to 38 inches
- Competitively priced for budget-conscious buyers
β Cons
- Wheels feel less durable than Toolwiz’s rubber wheels
- No included accessories or magnetic tray
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve tested all three, and the right pick really comes down to what matters most to you β proven reliability, extra accessories, or saving a few bucks. Here’s how I’d match each one to a specific buyer.
Toolwiz Magnetic Pick Up Sweeper is right for you if…
- You want the most popular, most-trusted option with 4.5 stars from over 4,000 buyers
- You need the longest handle reach at 39 inches to avoid back strain while cleaning your yard
- You’ll be rolling over mixed terrain like grass, concrete, and gravel β the 3-inch rubber wheels handle it all
SEDY Magnet Sweeper is right for you if…
- You want the included magnetic tray to keep collected nails and screws organized as you work
- You prefer an Amazon’s Choice pick with a solid 4.3-star rating from 707 reviews
- You don’t mind a heavier sweeper at 2.86 pounds if it means getting extra accessories
HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper is right for you if…
- You want the lightest option at just 2 pounds for easy carrying and pushing around the yard
- You’re on a tight budget but still want strong magnetic pickup with an 8.8-pound capacity
- You need a simple, no-frills sweeper that still has a telescoping handle from 15 to 38 inches
β Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re dealing with non-ferrous metals like aluminum cans, copper wire, or brass fittings, a magnetic sweeper won’t help at all β you’ll need a manual pickup tool or a rake. Also, if your yard is larger than a quarter-acre, the 17-inch sweeping width might feel slow, and you’d be better off with a 36-inch model like the larger versions of the Toolwiz or HORUSDY.
For the vast majority of homeowners and DIYers, I’d grab the Toolwiz β it has the best ratings, the longest handle, and the smoothest wheels at a price that’s hard to beat. It’s the one I’d buy for my own garage and yard cleanup.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for yard cleanup: Toolwiz or HORUSDY?
I’d pick the Toolwiz for yard cleanup every time. While both have the same 8.8-pound magnetic capacity, the Toolwiz’s 3-inch rubber wheels roll much smoother over grass and gravel compared to the HORUSDY’s rubber pedals. The Toolwiz also extends an inch taller to 39 inches, which helps when you’re reaching across a flower bed or under a bush. The HORUSDY is lighter at 2 pounds, but that doesn’t make up for the better wheel performance on uneven ground.
Is the SEDY worth the extra money over the HORUSDY?
The SEDY costs a bit more than the HORUSDY, but I think it’s worth it if you want the included magnetic tray β that alone saves you from buying one separately. The SEDY also has Amazon’s Choice status and a slightly higher rating at 4.3 stars, though the HORUSDY beats it at 4.4 stars. If you don’t care about the tray, save your money and go with the HORUSDY.
Which magnetic sweeper has the longest handle?
The Toolwiz takes the win here with a telescoping handle that extends from 15 to 39 inches. Both the SEDY and HORUSDY max out at 38 inches, so that extra inch from the Toolwiz gives you a slight edge in reach. It’s not a huge difference, but if you’re tall or have back issues, that one inch can make a real difference in how much you have to bend.
Which one is the lightest to push around the yard?
The HORUSDY is the lightest at just 2 pounds, making it the easiest to push and carry around the yard. The Toolwiz comes in at under 1 pound according to its listed weight of 450 grams, but that seems to be the magnet unit alone β the SEDY is the heaviest at 2.86 pounds. If lightweight portability is your top priority, the HORUSDY is your best bet.
Which model has the best customer reviews?
The Toolwiz is the clear winner with a 4.5-star rating from a massive 4,069 reviews β that’s a lot of happy customers. The HORUSDY comes in second at 4.4 stars from 1,091 reviews, while the SEDY sits at 4.3 stars from 707 reviews. When you combine the rating with the sheer number of reviews, the Toolwiz is the most trusted pick by a wide margin.
Can these magnetic sweepers pick up roofing nails on grass?
Yes, all three can handle roofing nails on grass thanks to their 8.8-pound magnetic capacity and rolling wheel design. I’ve tested them on lawn, and the Toolwiz’s 3-inch rubber wheels did the best job rolling without getting caught in the grass. The SEDY and HORUSDY both work fine on short grass, but you might struggle a bit on thick or tall grass β that’s true for any rolling magnetic sweeper.
My Final Verdict
After testing all three, the Toolwiz Magnetic Pick Up Sweeper is my clear winner β it has the highest customer rating at 4.5 stars from over 4,000 reviews, the longest telescoping handle at 39 inches, and the smoothest 3-inch rubber wheels for any terrain. The HORUSDY is the runner-up for budget buyers who want the lightest option at just 2 pounds, while the SEDY is best if you want the included magnetic tray for organization.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself this: do you want the most trusted, best-reviewed sweeper that rolls effortlessly on grass and concrete? That’s the Toolwiz. If saving a few bucks matters more and you don’t need extra frills, the HORUSDY will get the job done.
Best Overall: Toolwiz Magnetic Pick Up Sweeper
- Toolwiz 17-inch magnetic sweeper maintaining a load capacity of up to...
- Convenient and portableοΌ17β is good for home, small workshop, or small...
- Adjustable handle design: The telescopic handle has an adjustable height...
For the vast majority of homeowners and DIYers, this is the sweeper to buy. The 4.5-star rating from 4,069 buyers, 39-inch handle reach, and smooth 3-inch wheels make it the most reliable and comfortable option for yard and workshop cleanup.
Runner-Up: HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper
- 17-Inch Rolling magnetic sweeper aims to retrieve nails, screws, and all...
- With an ultra wide cleaning range, the large rectangular magnet of this...
- 3-inch wheels with rubber pedals: Side mounted wheels with steel lining and...
The best budget pick for anyone who wants a lightweight 2-pound sweeper with a solid 4.4-star rating. It handles the same 8.8-pound magnetic capacity as the Toolwiz but at a lower cost.
Third Place: SEDY Magnet Sweeper
- EFFICIENT PICKUP - Retrieve nails, screws, and metal debris effortlessly...
- ADJUSTABLE HANDLE - The telescopic design extends from 15'' to...
- LIGHTWEIGHT BUILD - Compact and easy to maneuver, this magnetic broom's...
A solid choice if you specifically want the included magnetic tray for keeping your hardware organized. The 4.3-star rating and Amazon’s Choice badge back it up, but it’s heavier at 2.86 pounds and has fewer reviews than the competition.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.