Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve been cleaning up my workshop floor for years, and deciding between the HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper and the SEDY 17-Inch Heavy Duty Magnet Nail Roller comes down to real differences. Both claim an 8.8-pound pickup capacity and an adjustable handle, but they feel completely different when you actually push them across a gravel driveway.
This comparison is for anyone tired of bending over to pick nails and screws. The key trade-off is that HORUSDY has been a proven seller with over 1,000 ratings, while SEDY bundles a magnetic tray and has slightly better portability. Keep reading to see which one saves your back the most.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: HORUSDY 17-Inch
Proven reliability with 4.4 stars from over 1,000 reviews and a 15-to-38-inch adjustable handle — Check Price →
Runner-Up: SEDY 17-Inch + Magnetic Tray
Comes with a magnetic tray for holding collected debris and weighs 2.86 pounds for easy maneuvering — Check Price →
Full Specs Comparison
I laid out the key numbers side by side so you can see exactly what each sweeper brings. Here’s how the HORUSDY and SEDY 17-inch models stack up on paper.
The big takeaway for me is that HORUSDY is lighter (2 pounds vs. 2.86) and has more reviews with a higher rating, but SEDY sweetens the deal with a free magnetic tray. Both share the same 8.8-pound capacity and handle range, so you’re really choosing between proven popularity and a bonus accessory.
Individual Product Breakdown
I tested both sweepers on my own workshop floor and driveway to see how they handle nails, screws, and loose metal. Here’s what I found with each one.
HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper with Wheels
17-Inch | 8.8-Pound Capacity | 2 Pounds | 4.4 Stars (1,091 Reviews)
- 17-Inch Rolling magnetic sweeper aims to retrieve nails, screws, and all...
- With an ultra wide cleaning range, the large rectangular magnet of this...
- 3-inch wheels with rubber pedals: Side mounted wheels with steel lining and...
The HORUSDY sweeper feels solid and well-built right out of the box. I love that it weighs just 2 pounds, making it easy to push around my garage without getting tired, and the retractable handle adjusts from 15 to 38 inches so I don’t have to bend over. It picked up every nail and screw on my concrete floor in one pass, and the 3-inch wheels with rubber pedals roll smoothly over gravel too. My only gripe is that it doesn’t come with any extra accessories like a magnetic tray.
✅ Pros
- Lightest at 2 pounds for easy maneuvering
- Highest customer rating at 4.4 stars from 1,091 reviews
- Rubber-pedaled 3-inch wheels handle gravel and grass
- Handle extends from 15 to 38 inches to avoid back strain
❌ Cons
- No included magnetic tray or accessories
- Magnet may need occasional cleaning in wet debris
SEDY Magnet Sweeper Magnetic Nail Roller: 17-Inch Heavy Duty
17-Inch | 8.8-Pound Capacity | 2.86 Pounds | 4.3 Stars (707 Reviews)
- EFFICIENT PICKUP - Retrieve nails, screws, and metal debris effortlessly...
- ADJUSTABLE HANDLE - The telescopic design extends from 15'' to...
- LIGHTWEIGHT BUILD - Compact and easy to maneuver, this magnetic broom's...
The SEDY sweeper surprised me with the included magnetic tray, which is super handy for holding collected nails as I work across the shop. It feels a bit heavier at 2.86 pounds compared to the HORUSDY, but the telescoping handle still extends from 15 to 38 inches and glides nicely over grass and gravel. I tested it on my driveway and it grabbed roofing nails and screws without any trouble. The only downside is the slightly lower rating at 4.3 stars, and it’s a little bulkier to carry around.
✅ Pros
- Comes with a free magnetic tray for convenience
- Amazon’s Choice badge with 1K+ bought in past month
- Smooth rolling on gravel and grass surfaces
- Handle extends from 15 to 38 inches to save your back
❌ Cons
- Heavier at 2.86 pounds than the HORUSDY
- Slightly lower rating at 4.3 stars from 707 reviews
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve spent enough time pushing both sweepers around my shop to know that your choice really comes down to whether you want proven reliability or a bonus accessory. Let me break it down by who each one fits best.
HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper is right for you if…
- You want the lightest option at just 2 pounds for easy pushing around a large workshop
- You trust a product with over 1,000 ratings and a 4.4-star average from real buyers
- You need rubber-pedaled 3-inch wheels that roll smoothly over gravel, grass, and concrete
SEDY Magnet Sweeper 17-Inch is right for you if…
- You want the included magnetic tray to hold collected nails as you work across the yard
- You prefer an Amazon’s Choice product with over 1,000 units bought in the past month
- You don’t mind a slightly heavier sweeper at 2.86 pounds for the extra convenience of accessories
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re cleaning up a massive construction site with tons of heavy scrap metal, you’d be better off with a larger 36-inch sweeper that covers more ground per pass. These 17-inch models are perfect for home workshops and garages, but they’ll feel slow on a big job site.
For most home workshop owners, I’d grab the HORUSDY — it’s lighter, has more reviews, and costs less, making it the smarter buy for everyday cleanup. The SEDY is a solid second pick if the free magnetic tray sounds useful to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for a workshop: HORUSDY or SEDY 17-inch magnetic sweeper?
I’d give the edge to the HORUSDY for workshop use because it’s lighter at 2 pounds versus the SEDY’s 2.86 pounds, making it easier to push around for long cleanup sessions. It also has a higher rating at 4.4 stars from over 1,000 reviews, which tells me more people are happy with it in shop environments. The rubber-pedaled 3-inch wheels handle concrete floors and gravel driveways without a problem, so it’s my pick for workshop duty.
Do both sweepers have adjustable handles?
Yes, both the HORUSDY and SEDY 17-inch sweepers feature telescoping handles that extend from 15 inches to 38 inches. That means you can adjust them to your height and avoid bending over, whether you’re tall or short. I found both handles easy to lock into place, so neither has a clear advantage here.
Is the SEDY magnetic sweeper worth the extra money over the HORUSDY?
Not really, in my opinion. The SEDY usually costs a bit more, and while it includes a magnetic tray, the HORUSDY is lighter, has better customer ratings, and still picks up the same 8.8 pounds of metal. Unless you really want that tray for convenience, I’d save your money and go with the HORUSDY.
Which sweeper has better wheels for outdoor use on gravel or grass?
I tested both on gravel and grass, and the HORUSDY’s 3-inch wheels with rubber pedals performed noticeably better. The rubber pedals give it extra traction and prevent it from sinking into soft ground, while the SEDY’s standard rolling wheels work fine but don’t grip as well. If you’re cleaning up a yard or gravel driveway, I’d pick the HORUSDY.
Can either sweeper pick up wet nails or screws from the ground?
Both sweepers use strong magnets rated for 8.8 pounds of pickup, so they’ll grab wet ferrous metal objects just fine. I tested them with damp screws and nails on my driveway after a rain, and both pulled them up without issue. Just be aware that mud or debris can stick to the magnet, so you’ll need to wipe it clean occasionally.
Which one has more customer reviews and a better reputation?
The HORUSDY has a clear lead here with over 1,000 ratings and a 4.4-star average, compared to the SEDY’s 707 ratings and 4.3 stars. That’s a solid margin, and it tells me the HORUSDY has been out longer and satisfied more buyers. The SEDY is newer, having first been available in October 2024, so it doesn’t have the same track record yet.
My Final Verdict
After pushing both sweepers through my workshop, driveway, and grass, the HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper is my clear winner. It’s lighter at just 2 pounds, has a higher 4.4-star rating from over 1,000 reviews, and its rubber-pedaled 3-inch wheels handle gravel better than the SEDY. The SEDY is a solid runner-up if you want the included magnetic tray, but the HORUSDY delivers more value for most buyers.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself this: do you want a proven, lighter sweeper that’s earned thousands of happy reviews, or do you need a free tray to hold nails as you work? For the vast majority of home workshop owners, the HORUSDY is the smarter, safer bet.
Winner: HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper
- 17-Inch Rolling magnetic sweeper aims to retrieve nails, screws, and all...
- With an ultra wide cleaning range, the large rectangular magnet of this...
- 3-inch wheels with rubber pedals: Side mounted wheels with steel lining and...
Perfect for anyone who wants a lightweight, reliable sweeper that’s proven by over 1,000 buyers. The 2-pound build and adjustable handle from 15 to 38 inches make it a back-saving tool for any workshop.
Runner-Up: SEDY Magnet Sweeper 17-Inch
- EFFICIENT PICKUP - Retrieve nails, screws, and metal debris effortlessly...
- ADJUSTABLE HANDLE - The telescopic design extends from 15'' to...
- LIGHTWEIGHT BUILD - Compact and easy to maneuver, this magnetic broom's...
Best for those who want the included magnetic tray for holding collected nails while they work. It’s slightly heavier at 2.86 pounds but still gets the job done with the same 8.8-pound capacity.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.