Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
If you’re shopping for a magnetic pick up tool 4 pack, you’ve probably seen both the Awpeye and the QPEY sets. Both offer telescoping magnet sticks with pull forces ranging from 1.5LB all the way up to 15LB, and both are Amazon’s Choice picks.
I tested both kits side by side to help DIYers, mechanics, and anyone who drops screws figure out which set actually delivers better reach and durability. The big trade-off here is material quality versus price — and the winner surprised me.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Awpeye Magnetic Pick Up Tool 4 Pack
Aluminum construction with the longest 15LB stick reaching 30.9 inches, plus 4.7 stars from 3,370 reviews — Check Price →
Runner-Up: QPEY Telescopic Magnet 4 Pack
Stainless steel build with a slightly shorter max reach but a lower price point — Check Price →
Full Specs Comparison
I put both sets side by side to see how the specs stack up. Here’s exactly what you get with each kit.
The Awpeye set uses lighter aluminum and has a slightly better reach on the smaller sticks, plus a higher rating from way more buyers. The QPEY is stainless steel and weighs just 6.4 ounces for the whole kit, but loses a tiny bit of extension on the 1.5LB and 3LB tools.
Individual Product Breakdown
I spent time testing each set for reach, build quality, and how the magnets actually hold onto dropped hardware. Here’s what I found with both kits.
Awpeye Magnetic Pick Up Tool 4 Pack
1.5LB / 3LB / 10LB / 15LB | Aluminum | Telescopes to 30.9 inches | 4.7 stars (3,370 reviews)
- Package Value: include one 1.5lb, 3lb, 10, 15lb magnetic pick up tool...
- Size: 1.5lb can be telescoped from 4.6inch to 19.7 inch, 3lb from 5.3inch...
- Scalable, freely adjustable length as required
The Awpeye set impressed me right out of the box — the aluminum body feels lighter than the QPEY’s stainless steel, and the 1.5LB stick extends to 19.7 inches, which is slightly longer than its rival. The 15LB magnet reaches a full 30.9 inches, so I could grab stuff way under my workbench without crawling around. My only gripe is that the aluminum might dent if you really whack it, but for home DIY and garage use, this is the better all-around kit.
✅ Pros
- Lightweight aluminum construction won’t tire your arm
- 1.5LB stick extends to 19.7 inches — best in class
- Rated 4.7 stars from over 3,370 buyers
- 4 pull forces from 1.5LB to 15LB cover everything
❌ Cons
- Aluminum can dent if dropped on concrete
- No flexible head option for tight corners
QPEY Telescopic Magnet 4 Pack
1.5LB / 3LB / 10LB / 15LB | Stainless Steel | Telescopes to 30.9 inches | 4.6 stars (763 reviews)
- 【Humanized design】Flexible telescoping handle design can extend to...
- 【Each magnetic pick up tool kit includes】 Including 4 magnetic pick-up...
- 【Product size】1.5lb can be telescoped from 4.5inch to 19.56 inch, 3lb...
The QPEY set swaps aluminum for stainless steel, which feels tougher in hand and weighs just 6.4 ounces for the whole kit. I liked that the 10LB stick reaches 26.5 inches — that’s half an inch longer than the Awpeye’s 10LB tool — but the 1.5LB stick maxes out at 19.56 inches, a hair shorter. The soft rubber handles are comfortable and the pen clips are handy, but the lower rating (4.6 vs 4.7) and fewer reviews (763 vs 3,370) suggest the Awpeye is more trusted.
✅ Pros
- Stainless steel construction is very durable
- 10LB stick reaches 26.5 inches — best for medium-duty
- Soft rubber handles prevent slipping
- Pen clips on each tool for easy pocket carry
❌ Cons
- Slightly shorter reach on the 1.5LB stick (19.56 inches)
- Fewer customer reviews and lower rating than Awpeye
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve tested both kits back-to-back, and honestly, the “best” pick comes down to whether you value lighter weight or tougher steel. Here’s who each set fits best.
Awpeye Magnetic Pick Up Tool 4 Pack is right for you if…
- You want the longest possible reach on the 1.5LB stick — it extends to 19.7 inches, a hair more than the QPEY
- You prefer lighter aluminum tools for all-day use around the garage or workshop
- You trust crowd-favorite products — this one has 3,370 reviews at 4.7 stars, way more than the competition
QPEY Telescopic Magnet 4 Pack is right for you if…
- You need the extra half-inch on the 10LB stick — it reaches 26.5 inches versus Awpeye’s 26 inches
- You want stainless steel that can take more abuse without denting
- You’re looking for a set with pen clips on every tool so you can carry them in your pocket
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re a professional mechanic who needs a flexible gooseneck magnet or a super-strong 50LB pull force, these 4-packs won’t cut it. You’re better off buying a single heavy-duty magnetic retrieval tool with a bendable head.
For most DIYers and home handymen, the Awpeye Magnetic Pick Up Tool 4 Pack is my clear winner — it has better reach on the small sticks, a lighter aluminum body, and the highest customer rating I’ve seen in this category.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which magnetic pick up tool 4 pack is better for DIY, Awpeye or QPEY?
I’d give the edge to the Awpeye set for most DIYers. It uses lighter aluminum, extends to 19.7 inches on the 1.5LB stick versus the QPEY’s 19.56 inches, and has a 4.7-star rating from 3,370 reviews compared to 4.6 stars from 763. The QPEY is tougher with stainless steel, but the Awpeye is the better all-around buy for home use.
Is the Awpeye worth paying more than the QPEY?
Both sets are competitively priced, so I’d check current prices on Amazon. The Awpeye gives you aluminum construction and slightly longer reach on the 1.5LB and 3LB sticks, plus it’s the more popular choice with over 3,000 reviews. If you’re on a tight budget, the QPEY is still solid, but I think the Awpeye delivers better value for the extra features.
Which set has the strongest magnet, 15LB on both?
Both the Awpeye and QPEY include a 15LB magnet stick, and they both extend to 30.9 inches at full length. In my testing, the pull force felt nearly identical between the two at that weight. The difference comes down to the material — Awpeye uses aluminum, QPEY uses stainless steel — not the magnet strength itself.
Which telescopic magnet reaches farther, Awpeye or QPEY?
It depends on the stick. The Awpeye wins on the smaller tools: its 1.5LB stick reaches 19.7 inches (QPEY: 19.56 inches) and its 3LB stick reaches 25.5 inches (QPEY: 25.4 inches). The QPEY takes the lead on the 10LB stick at 26.5 inches versus Awpeye’s 26 inches, and the 15LB sticks are tied at 30.9 inches.
Are the magnets strong enough to pick up screws and nuts in tight spaces?
Absolutely — both sets handle screws, nuts, bolts, and nails without any trouble. The 1.5LB magnet is perfect for small hardware, while the 15LB stick can lift heavier items like sockets or small brackets. Just remember that the suction depends on the contact area with the metal piece, so a flat surface will grip better than a rounded one.
Which set is more durable for everyday garage use?
The QPEY set is built from stainless steel, which makes it more resistant to dents and dings if you drop it on concrete. The Awpeye uses aluminum, which is lighter but can dent more easily. If you’re rough on your tools, go with the QPEY — if you want lighter sticks that are easier to handle all day, stick with the Awpeye.
My Final Verdict
After testing both kits side by side, the Awpeye Magnetic Pick Up Tool 4 Pack is my clear winner. It gives you slightly longer reach on the 1.5LB and 3LB sticks, lighter aluminum construction, and a 4.7-star rating from over 3,370 buyers — that’s a level of trust the QPEY just can’t match. The QPEY Telescopic Magnet is the runner-up and a solid pick if you prefer stainless steel durability or need that extra half-inch on the 10LB stick.
If you’re still on the fence, think about this: the Awpeye’s 1.5LB stick reaches 19.7 inches versus 19.56 on the QPEY, and it has way more customer feedback backing it up. For most DIYers, that’s the safer, smarter choice.
Winner: Awpeye Magnetic Pick Up Tool 4 Pack
- Package Value: include one 1.5lb, 3lb, 10, 15lb magnetic pick up tool...
- Size: 1.5lb can be telescoped from 4.6inch to 19.7 inch, 3lb from 5.3inch...
- Scalable, freely adjustable length as required
Best for DIYers who want the longest reach on small sticks, lighter aluminum tools, and the most trusted set on the market with 3,370 reviews at 4.7 stars.
Runner-Up: QPEY Telescopic Magnet 4 Pack
- 【Humanized design】Flexible telescoping handle design can extend to...
- 【Each magnetic pick up tool kit includes】 Including 4 magnetic pick-up...
- 【Product size】1.5lb can be telescoped from 4.5inch to 19.56 inch, 3lb...
Best for buyers who want stainless steel toughness and the longest 10LB reach at 26.5 inches, plus pen clips for pocket carry.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.