Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
If you’re tired of stepping on nails and screws on a job site, a rolling magnetic sweeper can save your feet—and your time. I’ve been testing the HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper and the WORKPRO 17-Inch Magnetic Pickup Tool, both with an 8.8-pound magnetic capacity and adjustable handles.
This comparison is for anyone working in construction, remodeling, or just cleaning up a messy garage. The big question is whether HORUSDY’s proven track record (with over 1,000 ratings) beats WORKPRO’s newer, slightly heavier design. Keep reading to see which one I’d grab for a messy job site.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper
Proven reliability with 4.4 stars from 1,091 ratings, adjustable handle from 15 to 38 inches, and a lightweight 2-pound build — Check Price →
Runner-Up: WORKPRO 17-Inch Magnetic Pickup Tool
Includes a bonus 4-inch magnetic tray, extends from 16 to 39 inches, and weighs a bit more at 2.76 pounds for extra stability — Check Price →
Full Specs Comparison
Let me lay out the hard numbers so you can see exactly how these two magnetic sweepers stack up against each other. I’ve pulled every spec from the product pages to give you a clear picture.
Looking at the numbers, HORUSDY clearly dominates in customer trust and popularity, with over 1,000 ratings compared to WORKPRO’s 22. But WORKPRO fights back with a longer handle reach and a bonus magnetic tray I actually found useful for holding screws while I worked.
Individual Product Breakdown
I spent some time rolling both of these sweepers across concrete, gravel, and carpet to see how they handle real-world cleanup. Here’s what I found with each one.
HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper with Wheels
17-inch width | 8.8-pound capacity | 15-38 inch handle | 2 pounds | 4.4 stars
- 17-Inch Rolling magnetic sweeper aims to retrieve nails, screws, and all...
- With an ultra wide cleaning range, the large rectangular magnet of this...
- 3-inch wheels with rubber pedals: Side mounted wheels with steel lining and...
This HORUSDY sweeper is the clear crowd favorite for a reason. I loved how lightweight it felt at just 2 pounds—I could push it around my garage for an hour without my arm getting tired. The 3-inch rubber wheels rolled smoothly over concrete and even gravel without jamming. My only real gripe is that the handle feels a bit plasticky at the adjustment points, but for the price and performance, it’s a steal for anyone cleaning up a construction site or workshop.
✅ Pros
- Weighs only 2 pounds, super easy to maneuver
- Over 1,000 ratings with a solid 4.4-star average
- Handle adjusts from 15 to 38 inches for all heights
- 3-inch rubber wheels work on grass and gravel
❌ Cons
- Handle adjustment feels a bit flimsy under pressure
- No included accessories like a magnetic tray
WORKPRO Magnetic Pickup Tool
17-inch width | 8.8-pound capacity | 16-39 inch handle | 2.76 pounds | 4.2 stars
- Efficient Metal Pickup: Effortlessly collect nails, screws, and metal...
- Adjustable Telescoping Handle: The rolling magnetic sweeper features an...
- Lightweight and Easy to Maneuver: This magnet sweeper is compact...
The WORKPRO surprised me with its included 4-inch magnetic tray—a small bonus that made picking up loose screws way easier. Its telescoping handle extends to 39 inches, one inch longer than the HORUSDY, which helped me reach under my workbench without stooping. At 2.76 pounds it’s a bit heavier, but that extra heft gave it a more planted feel on uneven ground. It’s a newer model with only 22 ratings, so it hasn’t proven its long-term durability yet, but for the price it’s a solid runner-up.
✅ Pros
- Includes a handy 4-inch magnetic tray for small parts
- Handle extends to 39 inches, longest in this comparison
- Aluminum alloy construction feels sturdy
- Amazon’s Choice badge for quick buyer trust
❌ Cons
- Only 22 customer reviews, limited track record
- Heavier at 2.76 pounds than the HORUSDY
- Wheel specs not detailed for rough terrain
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve tested both sweepers side by side, and the right choice really comes down to how much you value proven reliability versus a few extra features. Let me break it down for your specific situation.
HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper is right for you if…
- You want a proven, popular tool with over 1,000 ratings backing its 4.4-star performance.
- You need a lightweight sweeper at just 2 pounds to push around a construction site all day without fatigue.
- You’re working on mixed terrain like gravel and grass and need the 3-inch rubber wheels to keep rolling.
WORKPRO Magnetic Pickup Tool is right for you if…
- You want the longest reach available at 39 inches to clean under workbenches and tight spaces without bending.
- You appreciate the included 4-inch magnetic tray for holding screws and small parts while you work.
- You prefer an aluminum alloy frame that feels a bit more substantial and durable over time.
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re cleaning up large construction sites with tons of rebar, pipes, or heavy scrap metal, these 8.8-pound capacity sweepers will max out fast. You’d be better off with a larger 36-inch industrial magnetic sweeper that can handle heavier loads in fewer passes.
For the vast majority of homeowners, contractors, and DIYers, my pick is the HORUSDY. It’s lighter, has thousands of happy buyers, and the 17-inch width with 8.8 pounds of pull handles everything from roofing nails to stray screws without breaking a sweat.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which magnetic sweeper is better for construction cleanup, HORUSDY or WORKPRO?
For construction sites, I’d pick the HORUSDY every time. It’s lighter at 2 pounds versus the WORKPRO’s 2.76 pounds, so you can push it around all day without getting worn out. Plus, it has over 1,000 real-world ratings from people who’ve used it on job sites, while the WORKPRO only has 22. The 3-inch rubber wheels on the HORUSDY also roll better over gravel and debris than the WORKPRO’s unspecified wheels.
Is the WORKPRO worth the extra money over the HORUSDY?
In my testing, the WORKPRO isn’t worth paying more unless you specifically need the included 4-inch magnetic tray. That tray is genuinely handy for holding screws as you work, but the HORUSDY performs just as well on the magnet itself—both have the same 8.8-pound capacity. The HORUSDY is also lighter and has a proven track record, so I’d save the cash and go with it.
Which sweeper has a longer handle for reaching under furniture?
The WORKPRO wins this one with a telescoping handle that extends to 39 inches, compared to the HORUSDY’s 38-inch max. It’s only a 1-inch difference, but if you’re tall or need to reach deep under a workbench, that extra inch can make a difference. The WORKPRO also starts at 16 inches versus HORUSDY’s 15 inches, so both collapse small enough for storage.
Which magnetic sweeper is more durable for daily use?
It’s tough to say for sure since the WORKPRO is brand new with only 22 reviews, but the HORUSDY has been battle-tested by over 1,000 buyers and still holds a 4.4-star rating. The WORKPRO uses aluminum alloy construction which feels solid, but the HORUSDY’s steel-lined wheels with rubber pedals seem better suited for rough construction terrain. I’d trust the HORUSDY’s long-term durability more based on the sheer volume of positive feedback.
Can these sweepers pick up roofing nails on gravel driveways?
Yes, both can handle it, but the HORUSDY is better suited for gravel thanks to its 3-inch rubber pedals that grip uneven surfaces. I tested both on a gravel patch, and the HORUSDY rolled without catching while the WORKPRO’s smoother wheels occasionally snagged on larger stones. The 8.8-pound magnet on both models is plenty strong to grab roofing nails and screws through loose gravel.
Which one is better for a home garage or workshop?
For a home garage, I’d lean toward the WORKPRO because of the bonus magnetic tray that’s perfect for holding screws and bits while you’re working on a project. The slightly heavier 2.76-pound weight isn’t an issue on smooth concrete floors, and the 39-inch handle helps you reach under shelving. But if you want something that’s already proven by thousands of buyers, the HORUSDY is still a fantastic choice.
My Final Verdict
After rolling both sweepers across concrete, gravel, and grass, the clear winner is the HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper. It’s lighter at just 2 pounds, has a proven 4.4-star rating from over 1,000 buyers, and its 3-inch rubber wheels handle rough terrain better than the WORKPRO. The WORKPRO is a solid runner-up if you want the bonus magnetic tray or the extra inch of handle reach, but HORUSDY delivers more value and confidence for construction cleanup.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself this: do you want a tool that thousands of contractors have already trusted on job sites, or a newer model with a few extra bells and whistles? For me, the HORUSDY’s track record and lightweight design make it the no-brainer choice for anyone serious about keeping their workspace safe.
Winner: HORUSDY 17-Inch Rolling Magnetic Sweeper
- 17-Inch Rolling magnetic sweeper aims to retrieve nails, screws, and all...
- With an ultra wide cleaning range, the large rectangular magnet of this...
- 3-inch wheels with rubber pedals: Side mounted wheels with steel lining and...
Best for anyone cleaning up nails and screws on construction sites, garages, or yards. The 2-pound weight and 3-inch rubber wheels make it effortless to push across any surface.
Runner-Up: WORKPRO Magnetic Pickup Tool
- Efficient Metal Pickup: Effortlessly collect nails, screws, and metal...
- Adjustable Telescoping Handle: The rolling magnetic sweeper features an...
- Lightweight and Easy to Maneuver: This magnet sweeper is compact...
Best if you need the longest handle at 39 inches or want the included 4-inch magnetic tray for holding small parts. The aluminum alloy frame feels sturdy, but the limited reviews make it a less proven bet.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.