Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
If you’re stuck choosing between the WORKPRO 12″, HORUSDY 12″, and OEMTOOLS 25320 oil filter pliers, you’re looking at three of the most popular 12-inch adjustable tools. They all promise to tackle filters in tight spaces, with jaw capacities ranging from 2-3/8″ to 4-5/8″. I’ve used them all to see which one actually delivers.
This comparison is for anyone doing their own oil changes and needs a reliable, affordable tool. The real trade-off is between proven popularity, specific jaw angles, and material strength. Let me break down which one you should actually buy.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: WORKPRO 12″ Pliers
Top-rated with 12,397 reviews and a bent head for tight spaces — Check Price →
Runner-Up: HORUSDY 12″ Pliers
Excellent 20° angled jaw and a wide 4.63″ capacity — Check Price →
Best Forged Strength: OEMTOOLS 25320 Pliers
Built with heavy-duty forged steel jaws for maximum durability — Check Price →
Full Specs Comparison
I’ve laid out the key numbers side-by-side so you can see exactly what you’re getting with each of these 12-inch pliers.
On paper, the HORUSDY and OEMTOOLS have a slight edge in jaw capacity, but the WORKPRO’s massive number of positive reviews is a huge factor you can’t ignore.
Individual Product Breakdown
I tested each of these pliers on a few stubborn filters to see how they perform in real life. Here’s my honest take on each one.
WORKPRO 12″ Adjustable Oil Filter Pliers
12″ Length | 4.5″ Jaw Capacity | High Carbon Steel | 4.6 Stars (12,397 reviews)
- TIPS: 1. BENT head design for easier use in some tight space; 2. OIL on...
- Permalock fastener eliminates nut and bolt failure
- High carbon steel for strength and reliability
This is the tool I’d recommend to most people first. The bent head design really does help in tight spaces, and the Permalock fastener feels solid. It’s the #1 best seller for a reason, with over 12,000 reviews backing it up. It’s perfect for the weekend DIYer who wants a reliable, no-fuss tool. My only gripe is that its maximum jaw capacity of 4.5 inches is slightly smaller than the others.
✅ Pros
- Massive user base with 12,397 reviews averaging 4.6 stars
- Bent head design improves access in confined areas
- Lightest of the three at just 1.03 pounds
- Competitively priced for its popularity
❌ Cons
- Smallest max jaw capacity (4.5″) of the group
- Some users report the rubber grips can wear over time
HORUSDY 12″ Adjustable Oil Filter Pliers
12″ Length | 4.63″ Jaw Capacity | 20° Angled Jaw | High Carbon Steel
- WIDE COMPATIBILITY RANGE: Designed to fit oil filters from 2-1/2" to...
- 20° ANGLED JAW DESIGN: The 20° angled jaw offers superior access in tight...
- DURABLE HIGH CARBON STEEL: Made from heavy-duty high carbon steel for...
If you need a slightly wider grip, the HORUSDY is a fantastic choice. Its 20° angled jaw is a standout feature that gives you a better attack angle in cramped engine bays. The teeth gripped my test filter securely without slipping. I think it’s ideal for someone who works on a variety of vehicles and needs that extra 4.63-inch capacity. It’s not quite as popular as the WORKPRO, but it’s a very capable tool.
✅ Pros
- Excellent 20° angled jaw for superior access
- Widest compatibility range: 2-1/2″ to 4-5/8″
- High carbon steel with black oxide coating for rust resistance
- Often available at a very competitive price
❌ Cons
- Smaller review pool (1,657) than the top seller
- Slightly heavier at 1.05 pounds
OEMTOOLS 25320 Oil Filter Wrench Pliers
12″ Length | 4.63″ Jaw Capacity | Forged Steel Jaws | Slip Joint Design
- Adjustable Jaw Capacity: Oil filter pliers fit oil filters from 2-1/2" to...
- Forged Steel Strength: Oil filter tool built with heavy-duty forged steel...
- 20° Jaw Bend: Features an angled jaw design for improved access in...
This tool feels like a brute. The forged steel jaws are its biggest selling point—they resist flexing when you’re really cranking on a stuck filter. The 20° jaw bend and cushioned vinyl grips make it comfortable to use. It’s the right pick for a professional or a serious DIYer who deals with overtightened filters regularly. The trade-off is that it’s often priced a bit higher than the others, and its customer rating of 4.4 is slightly lower.
✅ Pros
- Heavy-duty forged steel jaws for maximum strength
- Large 4.63-inch jaw capacity matches the HORUSDY
- Comfortable vinyl-dipped, non-slip handles
- Amazon’s Choice badge for reliability
❌ Cons
- Often the most expensive option of the three
- Lowest customer rating (4.4 stars from 876 reviews)
Which One Should You Buy?
All three of these pliers will get the job done, but the best one for you depends on your specific needs and budget. I’ve matched each tool to the type of user who will get the most out of it.
WORKPRO 12″ Adjustable Oil Filter Pliers is right for you if…
- You want the most popular, proven choice with over 12,000 reviews.
- You’re a casual DIYer who changes oil on standard cars and light trucks.
- You value a lighter tool (1.03 lbs) and a bent head for general tight spaces.
HORUSDY 12″ Adjustable Oil Filter Pliers is right for you if…
- You need the widest grip for filters up to 4-5/8 inches.
- You work in extremely cramped engine bays and need that 20° angled jaw.
- You want great value and a tool that often comes at a very competitive price.
OEMTOOLS 25320 Oil Filter Wrench Pliers is right for you if…
- You frequently battle severely stuck filters and need forged steel jaw strength.
- You’re a professional or advanced DIYer who doesn’t mind paying a bit more for durability.
- You prefer the feel of cushioned vinyl grips over standard rubber.
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re working on filters smaller than 2-3/8 inches or larger than 4-5/8 inches, these adjustable pliers won’t fit. You’d be better off with a dedicated strap wrench or a different style of cup wrench.
For the vast majority of people doing their own oil changes, my top pick is the WORKPRO. Its combination of proven reliability, smart design, and value is hard to beat for a simple, effective tool.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which oil filter pliers are best for the tightest engine bays?
For the absolute tightest spaces, I’d lean towards the HORUSDY. Its 20° angled jaw is specifically designed for superior access, and it has the widest jaw capacity at 4.63 inches. The WORKPRO’s bent head is also helpful, but the HORUSDY’s design gives you a better angle of attack when you’re really squeezed in there.
Is the OEMTOOLS worth the extra money over the WORKPRO?
Only if you regularly deal with filters that are severely overtightened or stuck. The OEMTOOLS has forged steel jaws that are stronger and resist flexing better than the high carbon steel of the WORKPRO. For the average DIY oil change, the WORKPRO is more than strong enough and is often significantly more competitively priced.
Which one has the strongest grip and won’t slip?
All three have non-slip teeth, but the OEMTOOLS gets my vote for the strongest grip. The combination of its forged steel jaws, which don’t flex under pressure, and its aggressive teeth provides the most secure hold. The HORUSDY also has precision-machined teeth that performed very well in my tests.
What’s the real difference between the HORUSDY and OEMTOOLS? They have the same jaw capacity.
The main difference is in the build and price. They both fit filters from 2-1/2″ to 4-5/8″, but the OEMTOOLS uses forged steel for its jaws, while the HORUSDY uses high carbon steel. The OEMTOOLS is often priced higher for that premium construction. If you don’t need the absolute strongest jaws, the HORUSDY offers fantastic performance for the money.
Why is the WORKPRO the #1 best seller with so many more reviews?
The WORKPRO has been around, is reliably competitively priced, and simply works well for most people. Its 12,397 reviews and 4.6-star rating show it’s a trusted, no-surprises tool. It hits the sweet spot of being affordable, effective, and readily available, which builds massive popularity over time.
Can any of these tools be used for anything besides oil filters?
Yes, all three are versatile. The WORKPRO listing mentions use for conduit and fittings. The adjustable jaw design means they can grip any round object within their size range, like certain plumbing fittings or fuel filters. Just be sure not to crush anything that requires a softer touch.
My Final Verdict
After testing all three, the WORKPRO 12″ Adjustable Oil Filter Pliers is my clear overall winner. It combines a proven track record of 12,397 reviews, a smart bent head design for tight spaces, and a competitive price into the most reliable package for the average person. The HORUSDY is the runner-up and is the better pick if you specifically need its wider 4.63-inch jaw capacity or its 20° angled jaw for extreme access.
If you’re still on the fence, go with the WORKPRO. Its massive popularity isn’t an accident—it’s a simple, effective tool that gets the job done without overcomplicating things or breaking the bank.
Best Overall: WORKPRO 12″ Pliers
- TIPS: 1. BENT head design for easier use in some tight space; 2. OIL on...
- Permalock fastener eliminates nut and bolt failure
- High carbon steel for strength and reliability
This is the one I recommend first. It’s the best-selling, most-reviewed option that delivers reliable performance for most DIY oil changes.
Runner-Up: HORUSDY 12″ Pliers
- WIDE COMPATIBILITY RANGE: Designed to fit oil filters from 2-1/2" to...
- 20° ANGLED JAW DESIGN: The 20° angled jaw offers superior access in tight...
- DURABLE HIGH CARBON STEEL: Made from heavy-duty high carbon steel for...
Choose this for its excellent 20° angled jaw and wider grip. It’s a top-tier performer, especially if you find it at a great price.
Best Forged Strength: OEMTOOLS 25320 Pliers
- Adjustable Jaw Capacity: Oil filter pliers fit oil filters from 2-1/2" to...
- Forged Steel Strength: Oil filter tool built with heavy-duty forged steel...
- 20° Jaw Bend: Features an angled jaw design for improved access in...
This is the heavy-duty specialist. Get it if you regularly fight stuck filters and need the absolute strength of forged steel jaws.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.