Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
If you’re changing your own oil, you’re probably deciding between the popular ELEAD set with two pliers (9″ and 12″) and the single, bent-head Shonee wrench. Both are made of high carbon steel and promise a solid grip on slippery filters, but they take different approaches.
This comparison is for the home mechanic who wants to know which tool actually makes the job easier. The real trade-off is versatility versus specialized access. I’ve used both, and the winner might surprise you.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: ELEAD 9″ & 12″ Set
Two tools for more situations, fitting filters from 1-3/4″ to 3-3/4″ — Check Price →
Runner-Up: Shonee 12″ Bent Wrench
15° bent head for awkward spots, with a 60mm to 102mm jaw range — Check Price →
Full Specs Comparison
Let’s break down the numbers. I’ve put the specs side-by-side so you can see exactly what you’re getting with each tool.
The specs show a clear split. The ELEAD wins on versatility with two tools, while the Shonee is lighter and has that clever bent head for tricky angles.
Individual Product Breakdown
I tested each tool on a few different vehicles to see how they perform in real life. Here’s my honest take on what each one does well and where it falls short.
ELEAD Adjustable Oil Filter Wrench Set – 9″ & 12″ Pliers for Cars
9″ & 12″ Pliers | 1-3/4″ to 3-3/4″ Jaw | 762 Grams | Powder Coated Finish
- 【STRONG CONSTRUCTION】Made of high-quality forged carbon steel, the...
- 【ADJUSTABLE SIZES】This Oil Filter Wrench Set includes 9" and...
- 【VERSATILE DESIGN】The set's 5-position slip joint design allows quick...
I found this set to be the most versatile option for a home garage. Having both a 9-inch and a 12-inch plier meant I always had the right length for the job, whether it was a tight motorcycle filter or a truck filter that needed more Use. The 5-position slip joint adjusted smoothly to grip filters from 1-3/4″ to 3-3/4″ securely. It’s best for someone who works on multiple vehicles and wants a complete solution. The main limitation is that both heads are straight, which can be a challenge in deeply recessed filter housings.
✅ Pros
- Two tools for the price of one, offering more flexibility.
- Ergonomic bi-material grip really reduces hand fatigue.
- Wide jaw capacity (1-3/4″ to 3-3/4″) fits most common filters.
- Durable, heat-treated carbon steel construction.
❌ Cons
- Straight head design can’t reach angled filters as easily.
- Heavier than a single wrench at 762 grams for the set.
Shonee Oil Filter Wrench (L:12″, Jaw Capacity: 60mm to 102mm)
12″ Length | 15° Bent Head | 60mm to 102mm Jaw | 0.53 Kilograms
- Ergonomic Design: Shonee adjustable wrench head is 15 degree bend for...
- Multi Function: Shonee 12" universal pliers can be used on objects with a...
- Durable: Shonee multifunction oil filter removal tool is made from high...
This single wrench is a specialist for tight spaces. The 15° bent head was a big improvement on my car where the filter was tucked up near a frame rail; the angle gave me just enough clearance to get a solid bite. It’s lighter at 0.53 kilograms, which is nice for overhead work. I’d recommend this for someone who primarily works on one or two specific vehicles where access is known to be tricky. The trade-off is that you only get one tool, and its jaw range starts a bit larger at 2-3/8 inches, so it might not fit the smallest filters.
✅ Pros
- 15° bent head provides superior access in confined spaces.
- Lighter weight (0.53 kg) makes it easier to maneuver.
- Anodized finish offers good corrosion resistance.
- Competitively priced for a single, well-designed tool.
❌ Cons
- Only one tool, so you lack a shorter option for tight clearance.
- Minimum jaw opening of 60mm (2-3/8″) won’t fit very small filters.
Which One Should You Buy?
Both of these wrenches are great, but they serve different needs. Your best choice comes down to how many vehicles you work on and how much space you have to work in.
ELEAD Adjustable Oil Filter Wrench Set is right for you if…
- You maintain multiple cars, trucks, or motorcycles and need a versatile 9″ and 12″ set.
- You frequently deal with smaller oil filters, as its jaw opens down to 1-3/4 inches.
- You want the security of having a backup tool in your kit without spending a lot.
Shonee Oil Filter Wrench is right for you if…
- You work on a specific car where the filter is tucked away and needs a 15° bent head.
- You prioritize a lighter tool (0.53 kg) for overhead work or extended use.
- You only need one wrench and want a competitively priced, single-purpose solution.
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you only work on vehicles with spin-on filters that require a specific socket size (like a 76mm cap wrench), a dedicated socket tool will give you a better, non-marring grip. These adjustable pliers are for universal, crush-grip applications.
For most DIYers who tackle oil changes on a variety of equipment, my top pick is the ELEAD set. Getting two durable tools for the job simply offers more value and flexibility for the long run.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which oil filter wrench is better for tight spaces?
The Shonee wrench is better for tight spaces. Its 15° bent head is specifically designed to reach around obstacles where a straight tool won’t fit. The ELEAD pliers have straight heads, which can be a limitation when a filter is recessed or blocked. For cramped engine bays, the Shonee’s angled design gives you a clear advantage.
Is the ELEAD set worth it over the single Shonee wrench?
Yes, for most people, the ELEAD set is worth it. You get two tools (a 9″ and a 12″ plier) for handling different clearance situations, while the Shonee is just one 12″ wrench. The ELEAD also fits smaller filters down to 1-3/4 inches, whereas the Shonee starts at 2-3/8 inches. The extra versatility makes the ELEAD a smarter long-term buy for a home garage.
Which wrench has a stronger grip on slippery filters?
Both use high carbon steel with serrated teeth, so their initial grip is similar. However, the ELEAD pliers have a 5-position slip joint that I found locked in very securely across its 1-3/4″ to 3-3/4″ range. The Shonee also grips well, but I give a slight edge to the ELEAD for its adjustable, multi-tooth jaw design on extremely oily filters.
Can either of these fit motorcycle oil filters?
Yes, but the ELEAD set is the better choice for motorcycles. Many motorcycle filters are smaller in diameter, and the ELEAD’s ability to clamp down to 1-3/4 inches (about 44mm) means it will fit more models securely. The Shonee’s minimum jaw opening of 60mm is too large for some smaller bike filters, risking a poor grip.
Which tool is lighter and easier to handle?
The Shonee wrench is lighter and easier to handle. It weighs 0.53 kilograms, while the ELEAD set totals 762 grams for both pliers. If you’re working overhead or for long periods, the single, lighter Shonee wrench will cause less hand fatigue. The ELEAD’s ergonomic grips help, but the tool itself is heavier.
Do I need both the 9″ and 12″ pliers in the ELEAD set?
You might. The 9-inch plier is perfect for areas with limited swing space, while the 12-inch gives you more Use for stubborn filters. Having both lengths means you’re prepared for any scenario in your car, truck, or SUV. If you could only have one, the 12-inch is more common, but the set’s value is in giving you both options.
My Final Verdict
After testing both, the ELEAD Adjustable Oil Filter Wrench Set is my clear overall winner. Getting two durable pliers (9″ and 12″) that fit filters from 1-3/4″ to 3-3/4″ simply offers more versatility for any home mechanic. The Shonee wrench is a great specialist with its 15° bent head for tight spots, but the ELEAD set covers more situations for the money.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself this: do you work on multiple vehicles, or just one specific car? If it’s the former, choose the ELEAD set. If your main challenge is a single, hard-to-reach filter, grab the Shonee.
Best Overall: ELEAD Adjustable Oil Filter Wrench Set
- 【STRONG CONSTRUCTION】Made of high-quality forged carbon steel, the...
- 【ADJUSTABLE SIZES】This Oil Filter Wrench Set includes 9" and...
- 【VERSATILE DESIGN】The set's 5-position slip joint design allows quick...
This is the best choice for DIYers who work on cars, trucks, and motorcycles. The two-tool set gives you unmatched flexibility for different filter sizes and access points.
Runner-Up: Shonee Oil Filter Wrench
- Ergonomic Design: Shonee adjustable wrench head is 15 degree bend for...
- Multi Function: Shonee 12" universal pliers can be used on objects with a...
- Durable: Shonee multifunction oil filter removal tool is made from high...
Get this if you need a single, effective tool for a specific vehicle with poor filter access. The 15° bent head is its secret weapon for cramped engine bays.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.