Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
If you’re changing the oil on your Toyota Camry, Tundra, or Tacoma, you need a 64mm 14-flute wrench for the cartridge filter. The two most popular options are the Motivx Tools MX2320 and the Spurtar 64mm tool. I’ve tested both to see which one you should buy.
This comparison is for any Toyota or Lexus owner who does their own oil changes. The real choice comes down to premium build quality versus a very competitively priced basic tool. Let me break down the details so you can pick the right one for your garage.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Motivx Tools MX2320
Fits all Toyota cartridge filters (1.8L-5.7L) with a notch-less design — Check Price →
Runner-Up: Spurtar 64mm Wrench
Budget-friendly 6061 aluminum tool for 2.5L-5.7L engines — Check Price →
Full Specs Comparison
I’ve put the key numbers for both wrenches side-by-side so you can see the differences at a glance.
The Motivx tool wins on nearly every spec, especially fitment and materials. The Spurtar is a simpler tool with a more limited scope.
Individual Product Breakdown
I tested each wrench on a stubborn filter cap to see how they performed. Here’s my honest take on what each one does well and where they fall short.
Motivx Tools Oil Filter Wrench for Toyota Camry, Tundra, Tacoma, 4Runner, RAV4 and More
64.3mm 14 Flute | CNC Machined Aluminum | Dual Drive (3/8″ & 24mm) | 6.3 oz
- COMPATIBLE WITH ALL TOYOTA CARTRIDGE STYLE OIL FILTERS - The Motivx Tools...
- WILL NOT BREAK TABS ON FILTER - This patent pending second generation...
- FITS A WIDE RANGE OF FILTERS - Outdated filter wrenches have limited...
This is the premium wrench I keep in my own toolbox. Its notch-less design is the real deal—it gripped my Tundra’s filter cap perfectly without touching the fragile tabs. I love the dual drive option; I could use my 3/8″ ratchet or a 24mm socket. It’s made from two grades of aircraft aluminum and feels incredibly solid. This is the one to buy if you work on multiple Toyotas, including smaller 1.8L engines, and want a tool that will last a lifetime. The only downside is that you pay more for that quality.
✅ Pros
- Fits all Toyota/Lexus cartridge filters from 1.8L to 5.7L
- Notch-less design prevents breaking filter cap tabs
- Precision CNC machined from 6061-T6 & 7075-T6 aluminum
- Made in the USA with a lifetime warranty
❌ Cons
- More expensive than basic alternatives
- Overkill if you only have one 2.5L+ vehicle
Spurtar Oil Filter Wrench for Toyota Cap Style Oil Filter Removal Tool 64mm for Lexus, Camry, 4 Runner, RAV4, Tundra, Tacoma
64mm 14 Flute | 6061 T5 Aluminum | 3/8″ Drive | 5.9 oz
- Application: The oil filter wrench for toyota is 3/8'' Drive, 64 mm Inner...
- Perfect Fit: This aluminum cup for toyota oil filter wrench is a perfect...
- High Quality Materials: For Toyota camry oil filter wrench is forged from...
The Spurtar wrench is a solid, no-frills tool that gets the job done. For the price, it’s hard to beat. It has four slots on the bottom edge that mate with the filter housing to prevent slippage, and it worked well on my Camry’s 2.5L engine. It’s made from 6061 aluminum and has a clean black anodized finish. I’d recommend this specifically for someone who only needs to service their own 2.5L, 3.5L, or 5.7L Toyota or Lexus and wants to save some money. Just know it won’t fit the smaller 1.8L engines like in some Corollas or Priuses.
✅ Pros
- Very competitively priced
- Four bottom slots help prevent slippage
- Forged from 6061 T5 aluminum, feels sturdy
- Amazon’s Choice with over 2,600 reviews
❌ Cons
- Does NOT fit 1.8L engines (e.g., some Corolla, Prius)
- Single 3/8″ drive only (no 24mm option)
- Manufacturer warns against using power tools with it
Which One Should You Buy?
Both of these wrenches work, but the right one for you depends on your garage and your budget. I’ll help you match your situation to the best tool.
Motivx Tools Oil Filter Wrench is right for you if…
- You own multiple Toyotas, including a smaller 1.8L engine like in a Corolla or Prius.
- You want the strongest, most durable tool with a notch-less design to protect filter caps.
- You prefer tools made in the USA and are willing to invest in a lifetime purchase.
Spurtar Oil Filter Wrench is right for you if…
- You only service your own 2.5L, 3.5L, or 5.7L Toyota Tundra, Camry, or 4Runner.
- Your main priority is getting the job done for the lowest possible cost.
- You only need a basic, functional tool and don’t mind the 1.8L engine limitation.
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If your Toyota uses a traditional spin-on oil filter (the kind that’s one metal can), you don’t need either of these. They are specifically for the newer cartridge-style filters with a plastic cap. Also, if you need to remove a filter that’s already stripped, you’ll need a different type of removal tool.
For most people who work on their own Toyotas, I think the Motivx Tools wrench is the smarter buy. Its universal fitment and protective design mean it will handle any job you throw at it, making it worth the extra investment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Motivx Tools wrench worth the extra money over the Spurtar?
Yes, if you need the extra compatibility. The Motivx tool fits all Toyota cartridge filters from 1.8L to 5.7L engines, while the Spurtar only fits 2.5L to 5.7L. The Motivx also has a notch-less design to prevent breaking filter tabs and is made from two grades of aircraft aluminum. If you only have one vehicle with a 2.5L+ engine, the Spurtar is fine. But for broader use and better protection, the Motivx is worth it.
Which wrench is better for a Toyota Prius or Corolla with a 1.8L engine?
You must buy the Motivx Tools wrench. The Spurtar tool explicitly states it does not fit the 1.8L engine. The Motivx MX2320 is compatible with all Toyota cartridge filters, including those on the 1.8L engines found in many Prius and Corolla models. Don’t risk buying the wrong tool; the Motivx is your only option between these two.
Can I use an impact wrench with either of these filter tools?
I strongly advise against it, especially with the Spurtar. Its product description specifically warns that using electric or pneumatic tools with high torque might damage it. The Motivx is stronger, but for both tools, you should use a hand ratchet. The risk of cracking the aluminum or stripping the plastic filter cap is too high with an impact.
Which one has a better grip and is less likely to slip?
The Motivx Tools wrench has the better grip design. Its patent-pending notch-less design grips the fluted plastic portion of the cap without engaging the fragile tabs. The Spurtar uses four slots on the bottom edge to prevent slippage, which works, but it still contacts the tabs. For a secure, non-slip fit that also protects your filter housing, the Motivx is the winner.
Do both wrenches work on a Toyota Tundra 5.7L V8?
Yes, both the Motivx and the Spurtar will work on a Tundra with the 5.7L engine. This is within the 2.5L-5.7L range that both tools cover. The choice comes down to your budget and whether you want the premium features of the Motivx, like its dual drive and notch-less design, for that same vehicle.
What’s the real difference between 64mm and 64.3mm?
The 0.3mm difference is about precision. The Motivx Tools wrench is machined to 64.3mm for what they call a “perfect fit” on the filter cap. The Spurtar is listed as 64mm. In my testing, both fit the standard 14-flute cap, but the Motivx felt slightly more precise with no play. It’s a small detail that reflects the higher-precision CNC machining of the Motivx tool.
My Final Verdict
The clear winner is the Motivx Tools MX2320 oil filter wrench. Its notch-less design protects your filter cap, it fits every Toyota cartridge filter from 1.8L to 5.7L, and its dual-drive and premium aluminum construction make it a tool you’ll only buy once. The Spurtar is a fine budget option if you only work on 2.5L+ engines and want to save money, but it lacks the universal fit and refined engineering of the Motivx.
If you’re on the fence, ask yourself one question: do you want the right tool for any Toyota job, or just the cheapest tool for one specific job? For the extra durability and peace of mind, I think the Motivx is the better value in the long run.
Best Overall: Motivx Tools MX2320
- COMPATIBLE WITH ALL TOYOTA CARTRIDGE STYLE OIL FILTERS - The Motivx Tools...
- WILL NOT BREAK TABS ON FILTER - This patent pending second generation...
- FITS A WIDE RANGE OF FILTERS - Outdated filter wrenches have limited...
This is the top choice for anyone who works on multiple Toyotas or wants the most durable, versatile tool. Its notch-less design and full 1.8L-5.7L compatibility make it the professional-grade pick.
Runner-Up: Spurtar 64mm Wrench
- Application: The oil filter wrench for toyota is 3/8'' Drive, 64 mm Inner...
- Perfect Fit: This aluminum cup for toyota oil filter wrench is a perfect...
- High Quality Materials: For Toyota camry oil filter wrench is forged from...
Get this if you only service your own 2.5L, 3.5L, or 5.7L Toyota and want a basic, functional tool at a very competitive price. It gets the job done without the premium cost.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.